In Iran, poverty and lack of internet make distance learning impossible
Issued on: Modified:
Iran, like many other countries hit by the Covid-19 outbreak, has closed schools and universities and prioritised online learning. But in a country where there is widespread poverty and some regions have no internet coverage at all, some students are locked out of virtual classrooms. A teacher who works in a poor neighbourhood in Iran told the FRANCE 24 Observers that he hasn’t been able to get in contact with two-thirds of his students since schools closed.
On 10 March, Iran’s Ministry of Education announced the closure of all schools and universities to slow the spread of the novel coronavirus. Iran has been one of the countries the hardest-hit by the virus.
On 4 April, Iran officially kicked off its national distance learning project. The Ministry of Education launched “SHAD”: an Iranian application that students have to sign up for in order to attend virtual classes with their classmates and teachers.
Previously, many Iranian teachers had been using Telegram or WhatsApp, two popular apps among Iranians, to reach their students. However, the authorities have banned teachers from using any foreign-based app for educational purposes.
Children must download the SHAD app (which only works with the latest version of Android phones), enter their national identity number, choose their school and their class and then join their classmates and teachers to follow lessons in the virtual classrooms.
There are more than 14.5 million students in Iran. According to our Observers and people who shared their experiences on social media, the work-from-home platform doesn’t work as it should: there are frequent errors, a complicated interface, and a painfully slow platform where simply “transferring a short voice message takes a long time”, according to our Observers in Iran.
بخشی از عملیات عجیب و غریب عضویت در سامانه وزارت آموزش و پرورش :)ملوان زبل (@Malavan__zebel) April 12, 2020
لامصب این UI بدرد دانش آموز میخوره؟ چند نفر دانش دارن این مراحل رو انجام بدن اخه...#سامانه_شاد#شاد https://t.co/0zoC958yTe pic.twitter.com/XpqadL5GbQ
This user explains that even signing up to the SHAD platform is very complicated and people often get error messages during the first steps of signing up.
Iran’s digital inequality
The main problem for distance learning in Iran is not that the application isn’t user-friendly enough.
While Iran’s Education Minister claimed only 7 percent of Iranian students have no internet access, according to the latest survey by The Statistical Centre of Iran in 2017, 28% of Iranians had no or limited internet access. About 80% of Iranian internet users live in cities and around 20% in rural areas. The Director General of Education Ministry of Sistan and Baluchestan Province – a poor province in south-east Iran that shares a border with Afghanistan and Pakistan – said that only up to 40% of students in the province had access to internet.
#اینترنت پر سرعت و فضای مجازی ندارن...linda rasekhi (@rasekhilinda) April 19, 2020
اما یک #معلم_عاشق دارن که خطرات و سختی کار رو تحمل میکنه و با رعایت نکات بهداشتی به کودکان آموزش میده تافرزندان این کشور آینده ای روشن داشته باشند
اینجاروستای ##دمقلی بخش ارشق شهرستان #مشگین_شهر است👌
Translation: “They have no internet, no social media, so their teacher continues to teach them while trying to observe the precautionary measures, in order to give them a bright future.” Photo taken in village near Meshgin Shahr, northwestern Iran.
However, according to our Observers in Iran and even lots of Iranian media, poverty is the principal problem for distance learning in the country. According to Iran’s parliamentary research centre, between 40 and 55% of Iranians live under the poverty line.
اين بچه ها تخته و كلاس مي خواهند اينترنت پيشكش !Marjan - Farahmand (@farahmand2856) April 14, 2020
وزیر آموزش و پرورش:دانشآموزان ایران تنها ۷٪ به اینترنت دسترسی ندارند
این مدرسه آنلاین است...
سیستان بلوچستان بیشترین آمار افرادزیر ۱۵سال را دارد و ۹۰%مدارس آن زیر سطح استاندارد هستند.... pic.twitter.com/MqfC960I1s
These kids don't even have a simple blackboard or a classroom. How can you be talking about internet?” This video was shared from a school in Sistan and Baluchestan Province in Iran.
Farzad is a teacher in Kashan, a city in Isfahan province in central Iran. He works in a public school located in a poor neighbourhood of the city, with many Afghan migrants in his class. He explains that even in regions that do have good internet coverage, many families cannot afford to pay for an internet connection and cannot attend the virtual lessons.
The first thing you need to sign up to the virtual classes is a smartphone. In the neighbourhood where our school is located, there are many people who have old mobile phones. Because of this problem, I've had absolutely no contact with 10 of my students [about one third of his classroom] since the beginning of the lockdown in Iran.
On the other hand, there are families who have smartphones at home but they don’t have an internet connection or only have very limited access to the internet. For many families here, internet is a luxury that they cannot afford. I know they’re poor so I can’t force them to buy more internet packages, otherwise they would have to cut some other essential good from their family expenses. One third of my students can’t afford the cost of internet.
A broadband connection in Iran costs about 9.20 euros per month, while the minimum monthly salary is equivalent to 110 euros, meaning an internet connection would represent about 8% of their monthly income. A broadband connection in France costs, on average, about 25.50 euros, while the minimum wage is about 1,219 euros per month, meaning internet costs about 2% of the income of a person on minimum wage.
In this second video from Sistan and Baluchestan Province, a student says: “Look, we have nothing. We don’t have benches, chairs or adecent blackboard here
Farzad, our Observer in Iran, continues:
Even with the students that I’m in connection with, what we have is not a virtual classroom because it is impossible to assemble all the students at the same time, because most of them only have one smartphone at home and it belongs to their father, mother or siblings and the whole family has to share it. So I just send them up to four hours of content and exercises every day, then when they do get access to a smartphone they can do them.
I compare them to my family’s or friends’ kids, where each child has their own tablet. This system built by the authorities is designed for students who come from middle- or upper-class families in Iran.
The poorest children in my classroom are from single-parent families; they’re Afghan migrants or their parents are drug addicts. The parents of students who are in a better situation are mostly workers in the factories or seasonal workers.
I’ve complained about this inequality in many occasions, but the only answer I received from the school management was, “If these students don’t have access to virtual classes, they can still follow their lessons through the TV”. Some Iranian state TV channels are broadcasting school classes every day. I watched these classes on TV. They are very old-fashioned and use a method that our students are not familiar with. And what's more, my Afghan immigrant students don’t even a TV set at home.
A teacher in Hamidiyeh [a poor town in Khuzestan Province in south-west Iran] uses her fridge to teach her students.
Two weeks after Iran’s Ministry of Education launched the SHAD project, the number of users on the platform has remained low, according to an official report. Only 24.6% of Iranian students and around 50% of Iranian teachers have signed up to the platform.
According to this official report, we can see that in the poor regions of Iran, like Sistan and Baluchestan Province, only 6.8% of the students have connected to SHAD. In Kurdistan Province, only 16% are using SHAD.
SHAD even has its critics within Iran’s parliament.
On 18 April, Hossein Mohammad Salehi, an Iranian MP from a rural region in Isfahan Province, told an Iranian media, “People in my constituency don’t have decent roads, they don’t even get TV reception, let alone the internet. The education ministry has to provide access to classes for everyone or they must end this unequal system.”
Article written by Ershad Alijani