The aim of the operation was to capture a drugs-trafficker. These police raids in the slums have increased under the cover of an accelerated growth programme; a federal government plan to undertake huge urbanisation works in the area.
Comment from our Observer in the shanty-town of Rocinha in Rio de Janeiro. Carlos Costa works for Viva Rio, one of the biggest NGOs working in the ‘favelas' (Brazilian slums).
I know that
it's best not to jump to conclusions when it comes to such a polemic situation,
but I can't see how the bullet that killed Agatha could have come from anyone
but the police. There are no drugs-traffickers in this area [one explanation is
that the police fired into the air, the bullet heading upstream from the
intervention zone, in Agatha's quarter], and it's proved that the police were
here when it happened because you see them on the TV, no matter what the head
of the operation says. It was, after all, a police vehicle that rescued Agatha
and her father and got them to hospital a few minutes after it happened.
The government strategy is completely insane. We're a community that's had not a penny of investment or a brick of infrastructure, and now they want to improve our lives with war-like incursions? The police can't stride into the favelas at their pleasing; they're either here all the time or not at all. It's a strategic error not to be where traffickers work. It should be remembered that guns and drugs do not grow on trees in the favelas. They're brought there from outside.
The accelerated growth programme will create jobs. But do they really think it's best to start the work with rifles? As always, the people who will lose out in this ridiculous war are not the traffickers or the police, but the workers; the ordinary people; the innocent ones who simply want to work and study in peace. This programme for the slums is a huge sham."
Photos by Carlos Costa