Was Taraneh raped and murdered, or did she never exist?

090814 Taraneh T.jpg

Taraneh was a 28-year-old beautician who was arrested by Basij forces, raped and tortured for 22 days, and then set on fire and left in the desert. At least, that's what dissident Web users say. According to the authorities, the woman in question has been living in Canada for the past two years; and they have evidence to prove it — they've interviewed her family. So who's telling the truth?

The story of Taraneh Mousavi emerged online on 14 July, when protest blog Iranian Leftists wrote about the suspected torture, rape and murder of a young woman after allegedly talking to a friend of the aforementioned. It reported that the beautician was arrested on 28 June along with around 40 protesters. Although she herself was not participating in the protest, it was said that she was detained for wearing high heels and fashionable clothes. While the other detainees were turned over to the police at Nobonyad police station, Taraneh was taken to a house in Hosseinieh Ershad district by the Basij militia.

The post reported that a few days later the family of the young woman received a telephone call from an anonymous caller who said that Taraneh had been hospitalised following an "accident" in which her womb and anus and were damaged. When her family went to the Imam Khamenei Hospital in Karaj to look for her, a nurse told them that a girl matching Taraneh's description had been brought into the hospital by plain clothes officers and then removed a few hours later.

Two days later, the website reported that Taraneh was dead. They published what they say is the account of one her friends. The alleged friend says that Taraneh's family received another phone call in which they were informed that her burnt body had been found in the desert between Karaj and Qazvin (north-west of Tehran).

The story caused such a hullabaloo online that it managed to reach Thaddeus McCottor, a Republican congressman from Michigan, who delivered a speech to Congress on July 20, asking Supreme Leader Khomeini to look at the photo of Taraneh, saying: "Here is the truth denied by Khomeini and his misogynistic murderous regime."

Contributors

“Now the family is being threatened by the authorities, so we can’t get any new information”

Shahrzad, 26, is a photographer who was protesting near to where Taraneh was allegedly detained. 

It was Sunday, June 28. I was in front of Quba Mosque. Some reformists were celebrating the anniversary of Hafte Tir [a deadly attack on Islamic Republic leaders in 1981], which caused the police to attack us. After hours of street clashes, I finally reached home and tried to call one of my friends whom I'd lost in the crowd, but she didn't answer her mobile.

A day later I heard that she had almost been arrested in a scuffle when, at the same time, they also captured many other people. It was later that blog posts about a girl called Taraneh began to emerge and we realised that she was part of it. But now the family is being threatened by the authorities so we can't get any new information.

Shahrzad's picture

Shahrzad

  • Iran
  • Photographer

Taraneh “alive and well and living in Canada”

It was not until this Tuesday however, that the Iranian authorities spoke up about the affair, on state TV channel Shabakeh Khabar (known in English as IRINN or Islam Republic of Iran News Networks). Journalists on the show said that fake reports had been posted online and claimed to have found Taraneh Mousavi's family, who they then interviewed:

Translation by Omid Habininia. Subtitles by FRANCE 24.

“This report brought even more doubts about Taraneh Mousavi than we had before”

Asal is a 23-year-old Iranian student living in Melbourne, Australia. She writes for the Iranian Leftists blog.

The IRINN report brought even more doubts about Taraneh Mousavi than we had before. It's obvious that the picture which the reporter showed to the family is not the picture we know to be of the Taraneh Mousavi we're talking about. In this "comedy family show" the mother and sister say they never heard of the Taraneh affair — when it's been all over the news! Then there's the farce when she answers the phone and then it mysteriously cuts out. The report is a joke.

In any case, it's not that unbelievable that a young woman was sexually assaulted by the forces. It something which many women say has happened to them in Islamic Republic jails. This case needs to be investigated by independent human rights observers or a very brave journalist who's not scared of getting locked up.

Asal's picture

Asal

  • Australia
  • Student

Comments

IRINN report shows the wrong picture to the family

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKqQn2L_oDI&feature=related

The picture shown to the family is the wrong one - please see the video which tried to cover up her murder.

Unregistered user

Taraneh in Canada

What I do not understand is why IRINN report did not do a live interview with the so-called Taraneh Mousavi in Canada (on TV showing her speaking) to onceand for all dispute this reported rape and murder. What i sae in the report was they called a woman in Canada who said "Hollo?" and then they were cut off. Nothing more. This could have been ANYONE. You cannot do a half-way denial of something. Arrange a live interview with her (televised) so that she appears onthe screen and then we will belive that this is not YET ANOTHER cover up by this dispicable corrupt regime.

Unregistered user

funnnnnny

as an expat iranian ive seen so many stories/play written on iranian goverment for past 30 years.
bunch of foreign government paid sold-out iranian trying to portray iranian in worst scenario possible.in any up rising/disbelieving in governments policies any where in the world it would create an story different to two side.
leave iran to iranian IT IS Enough of putting your foreign nose in other countries business.
we seen these propaganda(during sadam invasion of Kuwait they brought a young girl to UN to tell the world a lie which was uncovered years later).
we all know the real British/french interest in iran,middle east & we could confirm firmly that their interest is NOT good & NEVER been good for people of iran

Unregistered user

Funnnny. You are not

Funnnny. You are not funy...you are just Stupid

Unregistered user

funnnny

Yes, and the story of the babies torn from their incubators was repeatedly circulated in the press, mentioned by Bush, the UN and Congress, and yet it all turned out to be an elaborate hoax. The young girl coerced into giving the testimony was Nayirah the 15 year old daughter of Saud Nasir al-Sabah,Kuwait's ambassador to the US at the time of the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait.

Unregistered user

how stupid is this Rejim

why they don,t interview to the owner of this photo.
they killed more than 200 people and they make stories about them,they are too stupid to think that people would belive them.

Unregistered user

Taraneh Mousavi Hoax and the Islamic Republic's Hoax

As I pointed out on my blog, both the Taraneh Mousavi story is a hoax and the Islamic Republic's denial is a hoax within a hoax.
As for the Islamic Republic's video,
1) There could not be only three Taraneh Mousavi's in the world. It would be like saying there are three Joe Smiths in the US.
2) It is impossible to believe that the daughter in this farce could not have heard that she was at the center of an international internet hullabaloo. She lives in Canada, according to the story, and would have free access to the internet.
3) The original hoaxsters would not have used a real person to perpetuate a hoax.
Read my blog and make up your own mind.

Unregistered user

Taraneh Mousavi Hoax

One needs to base one's arguements on known facts not on what one feels is believable or not.

1) do you have the known records for all Tarahneh Mousavi's aged 28Years?

2) I have just returned from a two month stay in Karaj and I didn't hear anything about this case. I can only conclude that there must be good chance that someone living in Canada may also not have heard of it. Furthermore not everyone spends their days trawling the internet.
3) This arguement makes no sense at all.

One could take many angles on this story - anyone out there who knows Farsi could put an interesting spin on the name itself.

Unregistered user

Taraneh story

For an in-depth analysis of how the Taraneh story emerged, see http://www.qlineorientalist.com/IranRises/taraneh-musavi/

Unregistered user

Where's the lady on that picture

You know What I think
This story is true
because it's typical our any oppressive regime
what everybody want to know where's the lady that appears on the picture
what happen to her ?
Please dont tell me she's canada because she's not otherwise the canadian foreign affairs would have comment on the subject
the lady is a unique child and doesn't have any siblings
so what really happen to her ?
I dont think that you can make up a story and you put a face on it and then claim it's only a hoax

Unregistered user