Raw video proves that “angry black woman” had every reason to be

090813 meet.jpg

The debate over President Barack Obama's universal health-care bill turned nasty this week when town meetings became chaotic. One in particular sparked an online debate after footage aired by news networks showed an African American woman being escorted out by police apparently disrupting the event. Images filmed from another angle and posted online by a blogger, however, proved that the story was not what it seemed.

Obama's controversial health bill is facing both public outcry and impassioned enthusiasm from respective opponents and supporters. Supposed to allow the public to air their views, town hall meetings set up across the country over the past week seem to have only worsened the situation after various senators were faced with furious outbursts and religious threats from angry opponents. One man turned up with a rifle strapped to his leg and a poster which read "It's time to water the tree of liberty" — a Thomas Jefferson phrase which is often used by white supremacists. Hoards of people tried to get into the meetings, but in most cases there was not enough room for everybody, leaving angry crowds outside waving the popular Obama "joker" poster and  threatening that they'd rather die than see the "Marxist Jihad" scheme come into effect.

Elsewhere, tearful backers told stories of victims of the current system in an attempt to convince their senators to push on with the bill. One of these supporters is the now highly debated "angry black woman" who is featured in the following video, filmed at a town meeting in Missouri held by Senator Claire McCaskill and aired by various news networks on Monday.

Contributors

Footage aired on the major networks (in this case CNN)

“An acceptable stereotype in American news: an ‘angry black woman’”

On Wednesday however, blogger Peter Glickert posted another video of the same scene from another angle. It not only shows the woman being escorted out but also what happened beforehand. Here's the video and his account:

Peter Glickert's picture

Peter Glickert

  • United States
  • Democratic Strategist

This is the only video of what actually happened at the event this afternoon. The news only showed the woman being escorted away by the police. What happened was that four women walked in with signs, the crowd booed and yelled at the women. The women rolled up their posters and put them down. A photographer/reporter approached one of the women and wanted to see what the poster was. As the woman went to show the photographer/reporter, a man from the bleachers stood up and snatched the poster from the woman and photographer/reporter. As the woman went to retrieve her poster, the police stepped in and escorted the woman and the man from the building.

The poster was not of Obama, it was not pro-health care. The poster that was taken from the woman and wrinkled up into a ball was of [African-American civil rights campaigner] Rosa Parks.

I do think that this is a race issue, because nobody said anything to the three white people holding "Don't tread on me" banners [see image below]. There's no doubt that there are serious racial undertones with the people who are anti-health care. They try to play it down but essentially many of them have a problem with having a black president, not with health care. And that's why as soon as I saw these four black women walk into the room with their Rosa Parks posters, I was sure something was going to happen.

The worst is that despite having eight cameras in the room at the time, the news channels chose to show only one part of the incident, which was a story about an acceptable stereotype in American news — an "angry black woman". While CNN went back and corrected the story after they saw my video, I don't think any other channels did.

“To them a late entering African American woman breaking the ‘sign rule’ is an outrage”

Another blogger who attended the event, Michael Bersin, backed up Peter's account and posted the following photos:



The poster displayed on entry to the hall.



The woman being escorted out by police.



After the incident, some signs still remain in the hall: "Don't Tread on Me" (anti-health plan).

Read Michael's account of the incident here.

Comments

Conservatives Now Outnumber Liberals in All 50 States

This post is for all those hatefull racist socialist liberals out there who make statements like this...

"I'm so shocked. This is pure racism. Even though I'm not surprised. I know that most of these people had something against the idea of having an African-American president.
At least this debate on the health care plan helps to expose pathetic people full of hatred."

http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/52602

Unregistered user

My thoughts on healthcare...

To believe in socialized medicine and socialized health insurance you must also believe ...
# You have to believe that the AIDS virus is spread by a lack of federal funding.
# You have to believe that the same teacher who can't teach 4th graders how to read is somehow qualified to teach those same kids about sex.
# You have to believe that guns in the hands of law-abiding American citizens are more of a threat than U.S. nuclear weapons technology in the hands of Chinese and North Korean communists and Islamofascists such as Iranian theocrats and Taliban terrorists.
# You have to believe that there was no art before federal funding.
# You have to believe that global temperatures are less affected by cyclical, documented changes in the earth's climate, and more affected by soccer moms driving SUVs and that the unusually cold winter of 2008-2009 should be attributed to global warming.
# You have to believe that gender roles are artificial, but being lesbian is natural.
# You have to be against capital punishment for criminals, even murderers, but support abortion on demand.
# You have to believe that businesses create oppression, and governments create prosperity. As a true Elitist Leftwing Liberal you have to believe that no Americans ever lost their jobs or became homeless except during the Reagan and Bush Administrations; these are problems that can be solved only by lotsa money and Liberals in the federal government.
# You have to believe that hunters don't care about nature, but loony activists who have never been outside of San Francisco do care about nature.
# You have to believe that self-esteem is more important than actually doing something to earn it.
# You have to believe that the military, not politicians, start wars.
# You have to believe the NRA is bad, because it supports certain parts of the Constitution, while the ACLU is good because it supports certain parts of the Constitution.
# You have to believe that taxes are too low, but ATM fees are too high.
# You have to believe that Lillian Hellman, Margaret Sanger and Gloria Steinem are more important to American history than are Thomas Jefferson, General Robert E. Lee and Thomas Edison.
# You have to believe that standardized tests are racist, but racial quotas, preferential treatment and set-asides are not racist.
# You have to believe that Hillary Clinton is normal, and really a very nice person even though the electorate outside New York didn't think so.
# You have to believe that the only reason socialism and communism haven't worked anywhere it's been tried, is because the right people haven't been in charge. You must also vociferously deny the fact that "Nazi" is an abbreviation for Adolf Hitler's Nationalsozialist party, because Hitler makes socialism look bad, unlike humanitarian socialists like Josef Stalin, Mao Zedong, Fidel Castro, Ho Chi Minh, Pol Pot, Saddam Hussein, Hugo Chavez and a host of other socialists who raped, tortured, maimed and slaughtered their own people in the name of "income redistribution" [ala Marx, Lenin, Stalin, Lyndon Johnson and Barack Hussein Obama], political and economic advancement for the "plight" of the downtrodden.
# You have to believe conservatives telling the truth belong in jail, but a draft-dodging liar and sex offender belonged in the White House.
# You have to believe that homosexual parades displaying drag queens, genetalia, transvestites and bestiality as well as organizations such as NAMBLA (North American Man/Boy Love Association) and other secular groups that promote pedophilia should be constitutionally protected, but symbols such as the Cross (Crucifix) the Star of David and manger scenes at Christmas should be illegal.
# You have to believe that illegal Democratic Party funding by the Chinese government is somehow in the best interests of the United States.
# When you don't understand your opponents' dialogue and/or are unable to refute their remarks, always claim comments are "divisive" even if you don't know the meaning of that word and "divide and conquer" is the leftwing modus operandi. You have to refuse to discuss the issues in a rational manner and whenever someone attempts to do so, throw a 3 ring tantrum, rant and rave, go into a lunatic rage and outshout them (preferably with profanity and name-calling) and stick to personal slurs, smear tactics, slander and building strawmen so you can knock down the strawmen (oops, sorry, strawpersons) and hopefully sidetrack the conversation away from your lack of ability to support your positions or refute the arguments of others. When you can't think of anything plausible to say, and name-calling and personal slurs are no longer working because people with IQs above ginger snaps can see right through such childish tactics, an especially effective prepubescent ploy that will at least convince other Elitist Leftwing Liberals, is to claim your adversaries hate America, or if you're on the cowardly side, indignantly ask them why they hate America even though it's obvious that its the Elitist Leftwing Liberals who hate America and Americans. Uncles Lenin and Stalin always urged us to accuse our adversaries of the very things we're trying to hide. It is the archetypal trait of the elitist leftwing liberals to camouflage confessions as accusations.... If you repeat this enough times, Elitist Leftwing Liberals will be offering awards - they may not be candy bars, but, you will be sure to win some snickers.
# You must always ignore the message and attack the messenger. When stuck, remember the tactic that won't reveal to other Elitist Leftwing Liberals your unwillingness to rebut the issue under discussion or your inability to think or say anything original: smugly change a couple of your adversaries' words, parrot and repeat their comments back to them verbatim and even if it isn't true, by all means always be sure to accuse your opponents of using the very tactics the Elitist Leftwing Liberals try to hide, remembering all the while that Unca Lenin would be proud as punch.
# No matter how credible a source may be - always do your Elitist Leftwing Liberal duty and rabidly claim it's been debunked and discredited and call anyone who believes it "mean spirited", crazy, a Nazi or any other of the secular monikers from the Elitist Leftwing Liberal grab bag of infantile epithets and sarcastic sobriquets even if you invented your "data" out of thin air or found it on the webpage of some Elitist Leftwing Liberal lemming on the lunatic fringe. See Article #27 for the suggested politically correct buzzwords to use in your tantrums.
# Whenever demonstrated facts don't agree with your agenda, twist them and mangle them until you can make them fit into your secular prejudices, the elitist Leftwing-Liberal mainstream media will assist you greatly.
# Once you've told a lie or slandered someone, be sure to repeat it as often as possible until it becomes true. "Members and front organizations must continually embarrass, discredit and degrade our critics. When obstructionists become too irritating, label them as fascist, or Nazi or anti-Semitic .... The association will, after enough repetition, become "fact" in the public mind." [ ~ Communist Party, Moscow Central Committee, 1943] and followed faithfully by the secularist, elitist American mainstream media lemmings in accordance with the precepts established for adherents to the code of conduct for Lenin's "Useful Idiots".
# You have to believe that all spirituality and all religions except Islam are bad. Remember, our secular saint, Uncle Karl Marx warned us that, "Religion is the opiate of the people". [Praising perversion is the opiate of the Left.]
# You must use the following buzzwords as often as possible without necessarily knowing their definitions: "Nazi", "Hitler", "gestapo", "police state", "police brutality", "totalitarian state", "imperialism", "imperialist", "running dogs of [fill in the blank], "greedy corporations", "shrub", "fascist", "paranoid", "paranoia", "goosestepping", "ruling-class", "class-strife", "class warfare", "stolen election", "unconstitutional", "racist", "entitlements", "hate", "bourgeois" or better yet, "petty bourgeois", "counter-revolutionary", "progressive", "red-baiter", "witch hunt", "inquisition", "anti-Communist", "deviationist", "revisionist", "reactionary", "multiculturalism", "oppressed", "unilateral", "victims of Yankee oppression", "plight of the [fill in the blank] people", "victimhood", "mean-spirited", "McCarthyism", "jingoism", "flag-wavers", "neocons", "alternative(s)", "empowered" and, of course, overuse of the indispensable "F" word.
# You have to believe that there were never any weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, even though they were used against Iran, the Kurds and the Iraqi people and even though the many Democrats warned us about WMD before the Iraqi invasion: William Jefferson Clinton, Hillary Clinton, Sandy Berger, Madeline Albright, Senators Carl Levin, Tom Daschle, Robert Byrd, Jay Rockefeller, John Kerry, Bob Graham, Ted Kennedy, Representatives Nancy Pelosi and Henry Waxman and vice-president Al Gore to name only the most vociferous.

Unregistered user

Can't help but think that

Can't help but think that it's the anti- health care (and those who leave essay-length comments) as the ones having tantrums. Couldn't be bothered to read the rest. I just cannot get my head around this tantrum. I know right wingers don't give a shit about anyone but themselves. I just don't understand it. You'd rather see fellow Americans suffer and die as a cause of poor health care than see Obama's plan - which would save you money - work? Someone explain me that!!! (and please, do it sensibly, not just bla bla Pelosi left wing 'radicals' etc.... it's not going to convince us if you tackle it like that).

Unregistered user

France24 plants SPYWARE on your computer

Youve been warned!

Unregistered user

Yeh, cos France 24, which

Yeh, cos France 24, which has budget like that of canary, has enough funds...and interest.... to plant spyware on your computer....

What would they find out anyway, from you pea brain computer owners... perhaps the french gov wiv their shit hot "social" health plan, might learn that private health waaaaaay better....
:D (joke)

Unregistered user

Heed Ronald Reagan's Warning

This is a short video explaining the reality of the situation.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fRdLpem-AAs

Unregistered user

So who in FRANCE24 is

So who in FRANCE24 is censoring my contribution to this article? FRANCE24 is CLEARLY a left wing propoganda rag,youre disgusting FRANCE24,you arent journalists youre little socialist stenogrophers who push the elitists agenda

STOP CENSORING PPL FRANCE24 !!!!!!!!!!!

Unregistered user

Hi, We don't accept copy and

Hi,
We don't accept copy and paste on this web site. But you're welcome to publih your own thoughts on any issue.

Team Observers's picture

Team Observers

  • France
  • Journaliste

"But you're welcome to

"But you're welcome to publih your own thoughts on any issue."

You mean unless they resemble someone elses, what I posted were MY THOUGHTS.

CENSORING JOURNALISM, NICE.

Unregistered user

What the?

Getting loud, violent and ugly over health care, something every major democracy already has. There is a great deal of ignorance and hate in America and apparently more than the usual percentage of nuts you find in any democracy.

Unregistered user

The way of life in USA

People do not care much for each other as soon they change the class.Classes are constructed on the financial base. Obama will have hard time to change something. I want ask Obama to retired petrause. I have got tired of sick messeges. I belive Swedish Gov. would fear and support just Petrause. Regardless on position people get sick and that is just so. Do not accusse Burma for him too. I need also that you block him all acccess to me and my family. I do not think to commite suicide but I will USE US gov. and Swedes cannot hunt my post endless. Thanks

Unregistered user

Here's the reality world

This is the real America. Most of my compatriots are incredibly bigoted. The same people that were "against big government" were no where to be found for the previous eight years of record-breaking government spending.

The elite scares these idiots into fighting wars and now into rejecting what would only benefit them.

Unregistered user

This is Jeremiah Wright. I

This is Jeremiah Wright. I predicted this. I said Obama was going to spark race problems when anybody disagreed with whatever his policy was, the people that defend him are going to come out and say it's all based on race. It's all happening.

Unregistered user

What's the problem, my friends?

Golly, you Americans! Social Health Care exists in many of the largest western democratic economies on this planet, and they are doing quite well, thank you. These countries apply many of the great ideas the U.S.A. has achieved and will achieve in the future, so how about, for once, if the U.S.A. applied one of the great ideas these countries have achieved?
Social health care is social as in social consciousness, not socialism,
and social consciousness, in my view, is more a sign of how free and democratic a society is, and by the way, democratic as in democracy and not as in democratic or republican parties. It's sad that grown up and mature people have to be taught the learn and appreciate the big difference. You hear social and you immediately think Russia. I hear social and I think of social democratic economic powerhouses like Sweden, Germany, and France, just to name three.

Unregistered user

"These countries apply many

"These countries apply many of the great ideas the U.S.A. has achieved and will achieve in the future, so how about, for once, if the U.S.A. applied one of the great ideas these countries have achieved?"

NO,sorry Thats like suggesting Cadillac apply some of the great ideas of Renault lol

"Social health care is social as in social consciousness, not socialism,

NO "Social healthcare" means me paying high taxes all my working like and even in to my retirement years for treatment I may or may NOT need,and if I do need it having to be queue'd and HOPE I can be treated BEFORE I die,or if I am lucky and my ailment isnt life threatening I get to enjoy the pain and discomfort until they decide im fit for treatement NO THANKS its my money I earned it and its my right to spend it how I choose NOT YOURS.

"and social consciousness, in my view"

This is not about you

"is more a sign of how free and democratic a society is"

NO people choosing for themselves how they spend their money is freedom,people choosing for themselves who will treat them is freedom NOT George Orwellian.

"it's sad that grown up and mature people have to be taught the learn and appreciate the big difference"

Like you apparently.

"You hear social and you immediately think Russia"

Gee I wonder why????

"I hear social and I think of social democratic "

You mean National Socialistic Democratic Associated Party?
aka the N.S.D.A.P ? look it up,google is your friend.

"economic powerhouses like Sweden, Germany, and France, just to name three."

You mean the United States,Russia an China? lol ask the Russians and Chines how they are enjoying their Socialism,their "socialist healthcare".Or the BRITISH even.

Unregistered user

"NO,sorry Thats like

"NO,sorry Thats like suggesting Cadillac apply some of the great ideas of Renault lol"
S
Strange that you are comparing the U.S. auto industry to Europe's. In case you haven't heard, the U.S. auto industry is BUST! Maybe Cadillac should apply some of Renault's great ideas, such as building more safer (all but one model got 5/5 stars at the NCAP crash test results) and fuel economic cars.

I suggest you read up on the benefits of Germany's social health care system. I imagine that Mr. Obama is basically trying to achieve something similar to it. It's not perfect but pretty sound, and I'm sure you will agree once you read it. Maybe then you will be able to recognize and perhaps understand what Mr. Obama is envisioning for the U.S. of A. You will be surprised how many freedoms the system allows you to have, especially about the freedom of choosing what kind of health care that you specifically want for yourself. It doesn't deny you any rights or freedoms to choose the health care you like, on the contrary, it gives you more options. The government doesn't force anything upon you, you still have the right to choose the health care insurance you want. It just makes sure that everyone gets insured. It has nothing to do with socialism my friend, just with social consciousness and social justice.
There are 40 something million people living in the U.S. of A. who are uninsured. That's not a standard for the richest economy in the world, it's more like a Chinese standard, if you want to talk China.

Unregistered user

You obviously arent an

You obviously arent an American saying silly things like that,and you MOST CERTAINLY have NEVER driven or have taken a ride in a Cadillac lol.

whatever the case you just dont get it,in the United states ppl live their lives the way THEY want to,NOT the way YOU want them too,You and I both know that EVERY SINGLE nationalized healthcare system in Europe is VERY expensive,reguardless of wether you need it or not,"Social healthcare" means me paying high taxes all my working life and even in to my retirement years for treatment I may or may NOT need,and if I do need it having to be queue'd and HOPE I can be treated BEFORE I die,or if I am lucky and my ailment isnt life threatening I get to enjoy the pain and discomfort until they decide im fit for treatement NO THANKS its my money I earned it and its my right to spend it how I choose NOT YOURS.

Europeans get really upset when they think the U.S is interfering with Europe,but its ok..RIGHTOUS even when they want to try to give lessons to the worlds only remaining superpower,esp when the U.S has given so much CERTAINLY much more than any other nation on the planet

Unregistered user

The Europeans are just

The Europeans are just concerned about the Americans. The U.S. of A. is becoming a dinosaur. Instead of being innovative and advanced, it's beginning to lag behind other countries in education, infrastructure, health care, and in many parts of the industry. The U.S.A. may still be no. 1 today, but if it doesn't shape up quick, it won't stay no. 1 for long. The New Frontier days in the U.S.A are over. You can't live your life the way you want to any more, because you're not alone on this planet. It's irresponsible behavior. I've been stationed in Europe, specifically in Germany for a couple of years, and from my observation, nobody was queuing in their social health care system. Like I said, it's pretty decent. Did you look it up? I strongly recommend you to read about social health care first before you unnecessarily put it down.

Unregistered user

p.s.

It will be easier to find the topic 'social' health care under 'universal' health care.

Cheers,

Unregistered user

"Golly, you Americans!

"Golly, you Americans! Social Health Care exists in many of the largest western democratic economies on this planet, and they are doing quite well, thank you."

Really?..like THIS?...."The incoming president of the Canadian Medical Association says this country's health-care system is sick and doctors need to develop a plan to cure it.

Dr. Anne Doig says patients are getting less than optimal care and she adds that physicians from across the country - who will gather in Saskatoon on Sunday for their annual meeting - recognize that changes must be made.

"We all agree that the system is imploding, we all agree that things are more precarious than perhaps Canadians realize," Doing said in an interview with The Canadian Press.

"We know that there must be change," she said. "We're all running flat out, we're all just trying to stay ahead of the immediate day-to-day demands."

The pitch for change at the conference is to start with a presentation from Dr. Robert Ouellet, the current president of the CMA, who has said there's a critical need to make Canada's health-care system patient-centred. He will present details from his fact-finding trip to Europe in January, where he met with health groups in England, Denmark, Belgium, Netherlands and France."...?

Unregistered user

MEDIA BIAS MEDIA BIAS

The article above is good example of the media bias in the US. You think the black lady was offended and the white people were allowed to show their signs, don't you.
Actually the entire meeting has been played on TV and the white people were asked to put their signs away prior to the white man taking the black ladies sign.
This is the media which twists everything here in the US to suit it's agenda. We are used to it and can spot them daily with bait and switch reports. That still does not warrant the man taking the ladies sign but the two were led out of the assembly because of the skirmish.

Unregistered user

I'm so shocked. This is pure

I'm so shocked. This is pure racism. Even though I'm not surprised. I know that most of these people had something against the idea of having an African-American president.
At least this debate on the health care plan helps to expose pathetic people full of hatred.

Unregistered user

"I know that most of these

"I know that most of these people had something against the idea of having an African-American president."

Amazing you just condemned virtually the entire half of the United States,you in one single condemning statement judged MILLIONS of Americans in every moral and Christian sense of the word !

"At least this debate on the health care plan helps to expose pathetic people full of hatred."

Like you apparently!

Unregistered user

Racism? you're crazy

You people are adding way way too much into the US Health Care nightmare by adding racism to it. In fact the average quite American is not only perturbed at the health care deal Obama has forced upon us but the entire attitude of our government. They are all elitest. They have lost contact with the people in general and do not recall that the people are their employer. And they are spending out of control.
Many of the people revolting against the administration are Democrats and fed up with the government taking over banks, the auto industry , the stock and bond firms and now health care. Obama has way overstepped his constitutional authority. Obama was elected with promises of having a transparent government with no secrets, let me state that this is the most secretive and conspiring administration in a very very long time. In fact there are many here that really fear Obama and his "real plan."
These town hall meetings started with the older people going and expressing their fears and objections to this plan. As the rage started spreading Democrat backed and paid for political group ACORN and some various unions have been being bussed in to bolster support for Obama. This is causing the friction with the local people wanting to meet their reps at these meetings.
You have not reported the skirmishes of racism being reversed by these ACORN people. One in particular happened in St. Louis, Mo. where union thugs supporting Obama beat up and severely injured a conservative. No your thoughts right now are wrong, the beaten conservative was a black man.447

Unregistered user

continued

Regardless of the hostilities, 99.9% of America is not racist. The real problem whites are faced with in the US now is reversed racism. If you don't beleive this just read the real transcripts of the Gates arrest and the following comments made by Obama. Anglos are walking on eggshells in fear of a race charge.
Some of the most crude racist are black lead by their infamous rattle rousing race bait leaders such as Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton. Many blacks are tired of their persistent position in the slanted news media which is terrible in the US.
I am a bit off topic but the basis of the outrage here is not due to race of the president. It's his inane lack of rediness for the job and arrogant way he thinks he is the ruler.

Unregistered user

You're talking about

You're talking about conspiring administration>. whatdo you think about the last one?

Unregistered user

Bush

I supported and voted for Bush. Many here and the news media were way overboard in criticism regarding him. The war in Iraq was pinned on him as being his idea alone. He had the entire Congress endorse all of his actions prior to going there. He was way more transparent than Obama.
As for him stealing the election I feel that was again a news media blitz. Yes it was close but the electoral college is their for a reason. If the last election was close the call would have gone the Democrats way.
The US news media is out of control, most true red blood Americans do not watch it because of their bias against Conservatives. They portry conservatives as rich, uneducated, racist, non-caring, etc. They could not be further from the truth.
At the end of Bush's tenure conservatives were against his handling of the immigration problem and the non-secure border we have with Mexico.

At the present time, if an election would take place next week the Democrats would loose big time, as they have proved they don't know how to govern the economy except by installing more government. This raises taxes and the US economy soars when taxes are low.

Unregistered user

Ah mon dieu! Que dieu

Ah mon dieu! Que dieu benisse les USA. Qu'est ce qu'il faut pour que les gens murissent et deviennent moins cretins. Un systeme de couverture sociale a la francaise ne peut qu'etre benefique. Alors pourquoi de telles reticences? Peut etre l'opposition a un tel programme a d'autres motiations innavouees.
J'ai entendu une americaine pestait contre cet programme criant qu'elle veut pas d'un pays comme la Russie. Il faudrait qu'elle se renseigne un petit poil. Le communisme en Russie est fini depuis longtemps et qu'y reigne un capitalisme plus sauvage encore qu'aux USA. Pourquoi dans les pays dits developpes il y a une grande ignorance?

Unregistered user

This is the ENGLISH section

This is the ENGLISH section the FRENCH section is the last door on the LEFT,thank you.

Unregistered user

Please learn french before

Please learn french before you attempt to use it,thank you.

Unregistered user