Multinational oil giant Chevron Texaco is facing the most expensive environmental lawsuit in history. Accused by an Amazonian indigenous community of contaminating the land with toxic waste, the world's third biggest petrol supplier could face a fine of 27 billion dollars.
The story began in 1990 when Texaco closed down operations in an Amazonian area in Ecuador, home to the indigenous Cofàn community, where Texaco had been drilling oil since 1969. In accordance with government regulations and to avoid legal troubles, the company said it would spend 40 million dollars on cleaning the affected area.
The cleanup however was far from what was hoped for. In Lago Agrio and other towns in the Sucumbios region, ponds remain full of waste left by Texaco, two decades after the company moved out. In that time, the sludge has found its way into groundwater and seeped into the surrounding soil. According to the local residents, these toxic substances are the root cause of serious illnesses (leukaemia for example), and consequent deaths. On May 27 their claims were backed up by the Pichincha local prosecutor, Augusto Semanante.
Fifteen years after the case began, the Cofàn community received good news as legal proceedings, which began in New York in 1993, were transferred to a court in Ecuador - largely expected to side with the plaintiffs. President Rafael Correa has done little to hide his own feelings about the "crime against humanity".
Chevron Texaco however passed the buck to Petroecuador, the state-owned company which took over as operator of the site, and condemns the Equatorian government, calling the case a "judicial farce". The American firm fears that it will not face a fair trial in Ecuador. The judge, a former army chief, has already given his opinion on the matter: "It seems like a fight between Goliath, and a group of people who can't even pay their bills".
Roberto Aguinda Lucitante, 39, is a tribal chief in the Sucumbios province of Ecuador. He's a plaintiff in the case.
I was born in 1970. The first pits in Lago Agrio
were built in 1969, so before I was even born my future lay in the hands of the
Chevron Texaco operation. Before the company set itself up here, the
Sucumbios region was owned entirely by the Cofàn people. Since, we've suffered discrimination; our
women have been subjected to attack and our rivers have been contaminated.
Now, we have less land and what we do have is riddled with petrol pits. We still have colonisers living here. Our culture has been impacted enormously. We can't feed ourselves because hunting and fishing is made almost impossible and there's no material for us to build our homes."
Chevron understands the
health situation faced by the residents of east Ecuador [translated from Spanish]. However,
after three years of misconduct from plaintiff lawyers, [their] failure to present
legitimate evidence to support their claims, judicial misconduct by the
Ecuadorian Court and most recently, joint interference from Ecuador government officials and the plaintiffs' lawyers to pressure the Court,
Chevron has called for an end to the lawsuit.
Trial evidence demonstrates that environmental pollution that currently exists in the Oriente is the sole responsibility of the government of Ecuador's own oil company, Petroecuador, which has owned and operated the oil fields for more than 15 years."
These photos were sent to us by the indigenous tribal chief Roberto Aguinda Lucitante. He accompanied the case's investigative commission when they visited the Sucumbios region in 2008. These images are of ponds and lakes in the Lago Afrio area.
Comments
Cleanup
Submitted by Nancy Spivey (not verified) on Wed, 24/06/2009 - 22:30.Looks like Texaco didn't clean up there mess before they left Ecuador. That is a terrible error on their part. Because this is going to effect the environment on a larger scale than just in Ecuador. It will effect our very atmosphere with the eco system being out of balance. Those poor people who can't even fight for themselves. I am tired of big corporations that are just out for the money and doesn't consider the little guy.
Unregistered user
Ecuador's Own Mess
Submitted by Jim (not verified) on Fri, 19/06/2009 - 22:00.It seems to me that Texaco did what they were required to at the time of their departure from Ecuador many years ago. The Ecuador government approved their cleanup projects and released them from future liabilities as the Ecuador oil company was to continue to operate the oil fields. It appears now that the National oil company did not operate in a prudent manner to protect the environment or the Amazon people. The total cost ($60 billion)quoted in the lawsuit is totally ridiculous and absurd. When will the National Oil Companies of the world step forward to operate in a proper manner to protect their people and their environment.
Unregistered user
Texaco did NOT clean up the
Submitted by Karen HInton (not verified) on Sun, 21/06/2009 - 00:51.Texaco did NOT clean up the pits. That's the problem. Texaco dumped dirt on top of the pits; that's like putting make up over skin cancer. Texaco lied to a US court, and Texaco lied to the Ecuadorians. Then, they took their profits and left their mess behind.
Unregistered user
What a mess
Submitted by Unregistered user (not verified) on Tue, 16/06/2009 - 19:02.Americans keep on pretending there is no problem for the environment! They mess up the planet and only think of profit. The big firms are now taking the planet over and we have to wake up fast and react strongly in this kind of situation.
Thanks for this article, it is really good, it just shows what Texaco did and how it reacts with no shame whatsoever.
Here is a link to sign up a petition: Try to save the planet:
www.copenhague-2009.com
Unregistered user
What's the link about? I
Submitted by U-user (not verified) on Wed, 17/06/2009 - 22:52.What's the link about? I can't read it, it's in French!
I get your point, but what can we do? We can't stop the big firms from doing all these shameful things, and even if we try our best to preserve the environment with small everyday gestures I'm not sure it does have an impact on the planet..
Unregistered user
It's a link to sign a
Submitted by Unregistered user (not verified) on Thu, 18/06/2009 - 12:05.It's a link to sign a petition to try to do somethink about the climat change: It is a letter to Sarkosy from
WWF-France, Greenpeace France, Action contre la Faim, Care France, FIDH
Nicolas Hulot, Fondation Nicolas Hulot, Les amis de la terre,Médecins du Monde
Luc Lamprière, Oxfam France Agir Ici, Réseau Action Climat, Secours Catholique to ask him to try to save the planet mainly by reducing gaz emissions when he is at the meeting of united nations at Copenhague.
You just have to give your email in the orange rectangle
Unregistered user