Is China racist?

This image was posted on various Chinese online forums:

 

Most of the examples are self-explanatory. Note that the watch-wearing crab at the end of the Chinese evolution line refers to how Chinese Web users describe government censorship. What people who came across the image found shocking was that few Chinese Web users had noted any offence in the Africa entry.

"People here used to think that white people were albino, hairy or just ghosts, and black people dirty"

Michael Anti, one of our Observers from Beijing, has studied and lived in the US.

I recall when I first talked to people in the States, it really shocked me that I could only use "African American" to label black people. Chinese Vice-Premier Wang Qishan, who gave an impromptu speech publicly in Maryland in May 2008, said that the American election had been between "an old man, a black man and a woman". He had no idea that it was regarded by most of the audience there as a racist speech. Then Taiwanese channel TVBS put up a headline saying "Black Horse Jumps into the White House". But the colour of his skin doesn't change the Chinese audience's passion for Obama; Chinese culture is just not a racism-sensitive one. Only Chinese people who have an overseas education would be shocked by this picture.

The Chinese nation has a long history of racial homogeneity. Ninety-nine per cent of rural people in China have never even seen a white or black person in their entire life. People here used to think that white people were albino, hairy or just ghosts, and black people dirty. They would warmly welcome whites and blacks into their homes while joking about their strangeness with fellow Chinese people. It doesn't mean Chinese people want to offend others. We have nothing in our history like black slavery as Americans have. Joking here doesn't trigger misery or pain."

Michael Anti's picture

Michael Anti

  • China
  • Journalist

"As for Africa, I think most Chinese people neither hate it nor love it"

River coolcool is a Chinese blogger and freelance engineer.

We believe the biggest racist in this world is the US government, and we are taught that most white people in the West are also racists... I promise you, neither I nor 99% of the Great Chinese people are racist. We hate racism. We only have prejudice. We never judge people by their skin colour, we only judge them by their social class, and most important of all, the contents of their WALLET!!

As for the picture, I think it represents a complex combination of feelings, which could warrant a book. Here I can only say, as Chinese netizens, we hate Europe (especially France recently), we hate the US, we hate Japan, and we hate Korea. In the meantime, we also hate our government. So in the picture, you can see both the stupid foreign apes and the crap three watches on the river crab. But as for Africa, I think most Chinese people neither hate it nor love it. In fact we don't care about it, and we know almost nothing new about it. It's here only to make the picture more ‘funny', and to satisfy some kind of vanity (not because of the skin, but the economy). Maybe such ignorance is just as bad as the supposed racism."

rivercoolcool's picture

rivercoolcool

  • China
  • Software engineer

Comments

1.3 billion racists

Yes based on this 1 picture we can definately conclude that all the 1.3 billion people on china are racists.

For those of you morons that are stupid I am being sarcastic and am saying you are stupid for even drawing any conclusions about a whole country from one isolated incident. Have a nice life losers.

Unregistered user

Hi all, I'm rivercoolcool.

Hi all, I'm rivercoolcool. Sorry for my limited English and jumbled thinking, but I wish you could read the words below. If there is anything I didn't express clearly, please tell me.

I just wanna say: if my comment seems impolite and offensive to you, sorry! ......But they're really not my first meaning. My original email to the editor of this website is just a low-quality, and somewhat stupid, "JOKING" comment on that picture. I didn't expect the editor would publish part of it. If you could see the many ":D" and ":)" in my original email, I think you would agree on that.

When I said, "...we (Chinese people) only judge them by their social class, and most important of all, the contents of their WALLET!! ...", and when I said, "...as Chinese netizens, we hate Europe (especially France recently), we hate the US, we hate Japan, and we hate Korea...", I was mostly JOKING, and only refered a small number of Snobs and "Feng Qing" (a Chinese word meaning "angry youth") in China, which kinds of people I believe also exist in any other country.

I believe most people would agree that, such words "......as Chinese netizens, we ......", or even the single word "we", are stupid. There are more than 1.4 billion Chinese people and 200 million Chinese netizens, so it's obvious that they don't think the same way, they don't speak the same words, and they don't hold the same hatred or love. Just take those "Feng Qing" (angry youth) for example, there are mainly two groups among them: one group "feel angry" with the Western, while the other group are angry with our own government, and loves the Western a lot. And please remember, both groups of "Feng Qing" are only minority of the Chinese netizens, and the Chinese netizens are only less than 1/6 of the total Chinese people—— most of which, I can still promise you, are not racists, but only common people, though with this kind or that kind of prejudices (not related with races) and narrow ideas, just like any common people in this world, like you and me.

So in my point of view, maybe the subject "Is China racist" is a good controversy question, but it's also a statistically bad question. I think all the Easterns, Westerns, Africans..., before quarrel and criticize, should try to understand each other more and better, through discussions like this, through serious books and objective media, through travelling to each other's country, and many other ways.

When I heard "I hate china" from some African readers of this article, I felt really sorry and sad. I just wanna say, most Chinese people like Africa, though they don't know much about today's Africa, just like many foreign people don't know much about today's China. And I wanna clariy again, most Chinse people judge a person definitely not by races, money or some similar things, but by whether this person is a good-heart person or not. Yes, there are many "political" (maybe dirty) things in the relationship between two countries; but as common people, not politicians, I wish we could base our love and hatred on the heart and character of a single person, not the country, race, liberature background or social class behind him/her.

As to myself, I'm a fan of many African national football teams (like Nigeria, Cameroon; and yeah, George Weah from Liberia, the super star in my heart when I was in high school). As a enthusiast of long running, I also admire both John Stephen Akhwari and Gebrselassie. And one of my dream is to see the High Mountain Gorilla by myself. I believe when talking about Africa, most Chinese people hold the similar feelings with me.

Sorry again for my limited English and jumbled thinking. If there is anything I didn't express clearly, or if you wanna discuss with me, please comment below or send me an email: rivercoolcool at hotmail dot com. Thank you!

rivercoolcool's picture

rivercoolcool

  • China
  • Software engineer

It is not about love, It is about respect!

You should know better and think better before you beging uttering garbagge about Black people! Being fan of African football players should not give you the audacety to insult my race with this racist article. Reading your note, I came to realize that you were actually ignorant about everything. The best thing to do when one doesn't know is to search and ask questions. I bet you will find an African who will help you understand who real Africans are and what they stand for.

Remember this, once and for all! We(specially younger generations of Africans) don't care whether or not people of other races love us. What we care about is people to respect us! That is not asking too much. Ignorance is a bliss!~. As a software ingeneer, you should know better. And having a college degree does not mean you know what you are doing either.
Get African history books and learn something about it. And make sure not to ever confuse those stupid African leaders with real Africans who care about their continent progress and development as well as the wellbeing of their people.

Lastly. We don't care if you hate Japoneses, Koreans or French. That is your problem, not ours. Just don't put Black race in that mess. Take care

Unregistered user

I wanna say sorry again

I can understand your angry. But please allow me to point out, both in my first comment in the article, and in the following note I posted above, I didn't say a single word "uttering garbagge about Black people".

But now I know my stupid joking words, or immature use of irony, is impolite and offensive to many people, so I want to say sorry again. More clarify is in my note above. Anyway, I think this incident is a lesson to both me and many other Chinese people.

rivercoolcool's picture

rivercoolcool

  • China
  • Software engineer

I hate china

As an African. I have never thought i will hate china or chinesse people untill i came accross this article. I am offended and the respect i had for china and chinese poeple has just evaporated for ever and i will make sure that millions of Africans get to read this article. Chinese precense in Africa will be threaten. Have a good day!

Unregistered user

I agree that you are very

I agree that you are very naive. Why would you hate the whole chinese race just based on some article? it sounds like you hate chinese people because they ignored your race. All of you are too hypered up and jumped to conclusions.

Unregistered user

you are not that naive

Just one drawing from someone exists only on internet can make your love and hate a country and the all people in it? In this case, you need to consider what you have learned from this website... ...

To any extend, this is personal opinion and view, I have no idea why people associate this with "Chinese" or even "China".

Unregistered user

African

You are a very superficial reader. You might have your eyes open, this does not mean you can see properly.I would ask you to go look at the entire blogg and see what chinese people say about it. Being naive is not knowing what is going on around you.

I actually think you are ignorant. If those stupid chineses don't want to have enemies then they should not insult my race! That is simple as that. If you have nothing good to say about it, then don't say it. People are not born haters (unless you are whites who have it in their genes),they learn how to become one.

Chinese people have created million of many enemies in Africa from this insult. The more we see this type of racist insults, the more the number grows.

We did not attack china or chinese people. They attack us!

Millions of young Africans are blogging on this topic accorss many universities for the past week. I will say to chinese people not to start anything they cannot handle. Have a good day.

Unregistered user

Trigger

I know you want to protect your race from racism after some hundred years, but I think it's because of those years that made you all so sensitive to any words or sentences that sounded racist to you. If every race acts the same, I think the comments would never end. The way you talk about chinese, white, and many other race is also racist. Because of this, they answer, and then you reply. When will it ever end? Stop being so self centered!

Unregistered user

Really? Are you SURE?

from your comment, it sounds like you are very well educated, but is this really how you think. This kind of thinking just flushes your education down the toilet. You are shaping your opinions about some race just because of someone's opinions. Is this how you were taught? to read those replies as facts? I know you all are very protective toward your race, but you need to think before you put down some rubbish that came into your mind while you were reading those OPINIONS!

Unregistered user

African development

I'm sorry, but the reason for your anger at the Chinese perception of Africa escapes me. Is it really that different from Western Europe, Austrialia, the Middle East, and even SOUTH AFRICA???

As a person of African descent, I am accutely aware of Africa's exploitation by imperial powers. It was, and is, wrong. But the truth of the matter is that Africa seems powerless, on it's own, to forward a united agenda of progress. This is hard for me to say, as a person of African descent - but it is true. Until Africa becomes a power, rather than a borderline slave nation of dictators and corruption, Africa will NOT be taken seriously by the Global Community. Period. EVER. Why is it so hard? How many times is the ball going to be dropped? There seems to indication that Africa will ever develop on its own merit. The dependence on Western charity has got to stop. Once that is done, Africa will be heard! China's perception of Africa is based on its global standing as a "child continent, inhabited by children", that cannot manage its own affairs with any measure of success.

I live in a comfortable place. I have almost limitless opportunity in my life. I have to admit that this is because of the Western ideals. One of the most important ideals - the one that I think is most responsible for Western success is summed up by Patrick Henry: "GIVE ME LIBERTY, OR GIVE ME DEATH." These are hard words. And even harder to fulfull in reality. But I guarantee you, until Africa is willing to make THAT deal, it will languish.

And, for the record, Euro-Asian racism and prejudice are still reprehensible and inexcusable. They just cannot be used as AFRICA'S excuse.

Unregistered user

You are not of African decent!

You are not of African decent! I will hardly imagine that. Or you might be a decendent of slaves who infortunately are slave minded. I see it alot in America and i have seen it in Europe. Either way, a true African will not talk as such in a way that attacts his own race rather than the continent ills. Why can you reveal your true identity? I actually reject your premises. They are sonelly based on the same ideologies of racists. As you said.You have a better life and live in a better place made possible by the Westerners. This is actually the cycle of dependancy and low selfesteem that you are showing, if you are really of African decents. Too bad, you know no better than those ignorant chineses. Trully, Africans are self critical and do critisize their leaders more than anybody. Even harshly so. However, that does not mean we should espouse the recist tactics used by others to undermine us as human beings.I have no problem with people of any race to critisize African continent or its shortcomings. We dont want to see anyone insult our race. Those are two different things not to be confused with one another. This racist chinese article as well as others perpetuated by the white racists and approved by their aculterated fellow decendent of African slaves(known as Diaspora,mixt races or pseudo African decendents)is attacking the black race! Look at that article very carefully and you will see. No country would want to live in a world with alot of enemies.China did not have enemies in Africa before, but with this racist article, they have created millions.I have sent this article to 120 bloggs accross Africa and i will do more. I am asking others to pass it on. Take care

Unregistered user

kid fight!

You sound so educated, but full of bs. you think you are some kind of leader? all you care about is your race, what about others? don't you all talk about other races too? This whole reply thing from africans talks crap about all the other races. you are very self centered and acted so rashly as to send this all around. you think you'll make a difference? you want others who were favorable of your race to think differently? This is so childish!

Unregistered user

We don't need your opinion

We, Africans, do not need your opinion. Quit franqly we don't need "others to be favorable for our race". We can care less what they think.That includes you. The commentary above yours is very good. Most Africans will approve it and agreed with it. The comment from my fellow African above yours can make him a good leader. He is thoughtful. Those are good qualities for a good leader.

So take note, The world is changing fast and deep!

Long life to AFRICA

Unregistered user

Poster Above, you are ABSOLUTELY Correct

Its one thing to criticize the political and social problems in Africa, but they have stooped to another level...

The politics in certain African nations is one thing, to criticize our race is another!

Many Chinese people have always been racist, and that goes for oriental asians in general

Many have come to kiss the boots and sell their soul to old-school racist whites (this occurred during the 40s, 50s, and 60s-70s when oriental asia was a geo-political battlefield), and have thus taken up their views...they are sheep

Black people act like this is something new...

SPREAD THE NEWS

Unregistered user

Is China racist

Does not surprise me that the Chinese are rather racially indifferent to people of African descent. Generally most of the world, European and Asian are either indifferent or harbour racist attitudes toward Africa. Whether its the begnin paternalism of Europe or the west, racial indifference as demonstrated and evidenced by china. There still exists a tremendous amount paternalism towards the people of African descent. And further, the world still buys into a lot of the myths and stereotypes of Africa and the people of Africa. Lastly, the picture in the above caption of africa shows just how shocking, appalling and anachronistic the world's thinking is regarding Africa.

Unregistered user

critical of china and rivercoolcool

I am saying all these confident of my loyalty and faith in Communism and the true values encouraged by it....

rivercoolcool you have proven what Chinese people think of themselves and the outisde World by your comment which lacks intelligence and is full of '45 style propaganda.

Thankfully there is no democracy in China or China would have become another Nazi threat to the world such as Japan and Germany once were.

You hate or dislike everybody else more than any country around you, you guys are so snobbish, so far from reality that you cant even see the standards or life you are living in and that is not the responsibility of the Chinese state or Communism.

That is in your genes, you guys are so used to living like peasants you have become genetically peasants, I have lived with Chinese students in a capitalist and democratic country and I have seen how you behave even if you are in the absolute minority and free of state control. And you see yourselves on top of the World against all odds. Thankfully your state is being controlled by wiser man than the average Chinese man like you.

You guys hate Japanese mostly not because of of WW2 crimes, but because they have always bested you in every subject, they are perfectionists and they succeed in that by surpassing any other country in the World in technology, while you are still living mediocre lives, and you cant take it. You hate any other advanced nation because of the same reason.

And for less advanced nations than yours, you see them as lowlife creatures forgetting what you had to go through in the past to come this far. Africa's progress has been inhibited by Western nations for more than 300 years now and still is being inhibited. They are divided and being ruled by profit-hungry nations, and finally you guys have joined the parade of imperialists by exploiting them for cheap slave like labor instead of giving them a helping hand to get over the spoils of war and imperialism (as Communism directs all nations to do so) SHAME ON YOU FOR THAT !

Average Chinese person is not aware of what is happening in the World and doesnt care too much about anything else other than whats happening in China. You, an ignorant mediocre peasant are a proof of that.

You guys ! open your eyes and wake up to the reality, you are at the beginning of 1900's in social standards and progress, you yourself are a backward nation ! Sending rockets to the space(thanks to USSR and Russia) or a modern army (thanks to USSR and Russia) doesnt make you an advanced nation.

You have failed to achieve most of the Communist goals, you are just another state-capitalist nation which exploits its own people and now is exploiting others too.

May there be mercy on mankind....

Ignorance is a bliss isnt it ?

Unregistered user

we don't care

"In fact we don't care about it"

That's absolutely right. Most of Chinese people don't care about others. They just care about their own family and very very close friends. And that's why we are upset.

As a french teacher in China, after almost 6 years working there, moving every year to a new city, I always see the same thing. They care when you arrive, you have to be their friends, but once the curiosity is over or once they got what they wanted they just don't care anymore. And they don't realize it.

So now, I don't care too and they say "you are rude", so I say "no" and explain to them that in fact they don't care.

Don't care about them and they will care about, and about you.

But on the other side if I stay in China,it is because I like chinese people and love China.

So soon, I'll get mad....

Unregistered user

Consideration!! Yah, yo! Be

Consideration!!
Yah, yo! Be careful of the way you joke though! Let your jokes remain in the boundaries, eh! I hope you know that even a right thing can offend if not properly said or said at the wrong time. I think you ought to leap before you act, hey! If you didnt know anything at all about Africa, apparently, as you claim to, why didnt you then think of making it a most charmingly beautiful thing? Anyway, I think there is still some small room for tollarence, but, think through things better than that next time, huh!!

Unregistered user

F OFF

YAH YO !

you can F-OFF my blissful friend

you think simple yapper like that will make any difference, WELL YOU ARE MISTAKEN

take is as an offense I wanted you guys to get offended, I thought you'd wake up !

You go tolerate yourself

Unregistered user

cool off man

maybe you should go put some ice on to cool off because yours is also simple "yapper". because your use of language doesn't sound like you care about what others think of your race. If you don't, then maybe you shouldn't be said anything. if you do, then use some proper language that will make others think differently.

Unregistered user

Chinese racism

"We never judge people by their skin colour, we only judge them by their social class, and most important of all, the contents of their WALLET!!" LOL!

"But as for Africa, I think most Chinese people neither hate it nor love it. In fact we don't care about it, and we know almost nothing new about it."

I agree that the Chinese "racism" stems more from prejudice and ignorance. I'm sure that a very significant number of Chinese (95% or higher) have never even met or seen a dark skinned person before in their lives.

Unregistered user

Rivercoolcool, go play in your farm !

River coolcool is extremely nationalistic..... he is also very irrational....what is the reason for hating almost everybody in the world? and hating France because of the Olympic torch thing or the Dalai Lama thing is just absurd! these nationalistic Chinese people are merely being used by their government to divert from their internal peoblems.....i wonder why do so many Chinese people want to emigrate to the West, IF they hate the West so much.......

Unregistered user

Dear sir Because just like

Dear sir

Because just like you people have said you people only judges people by their social class and the content of their wallets. You people respects people with better position in the society regardless of their skin colors and ethnicity, you people respect them as long as they have money and i respected you people for that.

But in Australia where white are China lovers have paid considerable respect to Chinese people and I have encountered several racism from the Chinese people in term of supremacy and prejudice personality. But besides that and the Chinese foods and China Olympic I have no other problems with the Chinese whatsoever.

Just once encounter that upsetting me the most is the time when i came across a Chinese salesman whom i paid $70 dollars for delivery of a computer desk I've ordered but it never come sir, why is that?

Could you please explain the complicity of the personality when it come to over races sir. I saw a great disrespect from their duel personality and sense of exploitation for money and a lying habit. Sir, please explain to me why there are so many lies in just one Olympic China?

Unregistered user

I think there are web

I think there are web graphics that make fun of everything that exists. It is funny it doesn't mean that it is offensive or to be take seriously. Just because I make a midget joke doesn't mean I am a mean person!

Unregistered user

they have no clue

river coolcool is both racist and stupid

Unregistered user

Really?

is this all you can say? Stupid and racist? apparently you don't know anything. It just shows what kind of person you are. You shouldn't even be saying anything, little kid!

Unregistered user

Consideration

Consideration required!!
Yah, yo! Be careful of the way you joke though! Let your jokes remain in the boundaries, eh! I hope you know that even a right thing can offend if not properly said or said at the wrong time. I think you ought to leap before you act, hey! If you didnt know anything at all about Africa, apparently, as you claim to, why didnt you then think of making a most charmingly beautiful thing? Anyway, I think there is still some small room for tollarence, but, think through things better than next time, huh!!

Unregistered user