Shocking police blunder caught on phone camera

A few hours after midnight on New Year's Eve, a 22-year-old African American was detained by transport police on a subway platform in Oakland, California. The man, who was unarmed, was pinned to the ground and fatally shot in the back. Filmed by several witnesses, evidence of the outrageous scene is now online and circulating the blogosphere. Could the images spark social unrest?

This video shows what happened quite clearly. At 36 seconds into the film, the officer fires the shot.

You don't see the actual shot in this next video, but it gives a good idea of what the atmosphere was like when it took place. As the tension mounts passers-by start to crowd around, and it's evident that the police officers are becoming stressed. We hear the gunshot at 2'56. As panic erupts, the girl filming the scene shouts "Oh my fucking god. They just shot him!"

The scene took place at around 2am on 1 January in Fruitvale metro station, Oakland. The victim, Oscar Grant, held a criminal record. The bullet fired by the BART (Bay Area Rapid Transport) police officer shot through Grant's body, hit the ground, and ricocheted back once more. He died shortly after being transported to hospital. 

The police were involved in several disturbances on New Year's Eve, including the questioning of armed individuals. The BART authorities explained that the officers we see in the video had just broken up a fight which had brought a metro train to a standstill. They say that the shot was accidental. One of the theories put forward by the American press is that the officer believed he was using a Taser gun and not a firearm with bullets. The victim's family has filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the BART police service, and on Monday a protest was organised in front of the BART head office.

Oakland suffers from a particularly high crime rate and tense race relations. Some 30-35% of the population is African American. Such an incident - caught on amateur film, which means a viral effect is certain - could add fuel onto an already simmering fire.

UPDATE (6 Jan. 08 - 6pm): we contacted our Observer in the Oakland area, Wayne Phillips, who told us that despite the incident coming as a shock, he doesn't believe the videos will cause active protest.

UPDATE (9 Jan. 08 4.30pm): Contrary to our Observer's optimistic analysis, demonstrations over Grant's death became violent on Wednesday night when hundreds of protestors took to the streets to condemn the shooting. Riot police faced the crowds with tear gas and arrested at least 14 people after shop windows were smashed and cars set alight. There are plenty of amateur photos of the events posted on Flickr, for example here.

Contributors

Comments

This is sad about what happen and should of never happen but

it was an accident. i dont beleve that it was done just to take another black person. Grant might have been fighting with police while the officer tried to put cuffs on him and since it seem none of the other cops were helping i think he wanted to reach for his tazer and give him a quick zap and be done with it but he was in a panic mode and reach for the wrong thing. and since grant happen to be black man made this situation turn into a hate crime which im sorry just does not seem right. if it were a white indian chinese or some other race i almsot garentee that (sorry for spelling) there wouldnt be protest but sience every one saw "white man shooting black guy hm hate crime" without even includeing the fact that it might MIGHT have been an accident. The longer people keep thinking this the longer raceism will still continue. And dont give me "oh its hard to be a young black man BS" they are put into this suitation by there mother and fathers who didnt want to get a F****** job and just sitting on their a** because they still have this idea in their head of "oh im black i cant do anything a white man can do" or just up and left cause they didnt have the money to take care of the or just didnt want them. they r doing it to themselfs blacks are causeing there own proviety no one and i mean now one is to blame but this what seems to be a circle of life for the black man(or women) starts out mother father or in some casues male female = sex father leaves = single mom with a kid with no father figure so the kid is going to find that father figure or some type of feeling welcome and with the media the way it is today he going to join a gang and then this shit happens. its there own falut so they should not blamed now one but themself face it (and i know some r not like this some have good familes but the ones that say oh its hard being black is just another excuses. Untill people stop seeing color and just see every one as 1 unit as 1 americans not black and white then rascism is never going away, i beleve when i see any race i see them as a person i dont see the colot of their skin but i do see theirpersonilty i see who they are not what color they are i think once people start seeing the same views as me i think that raceism has a chance of being no more but theres just to manny ignotiant people out there (of all races blacks and whites and if you dont beleve me go to kkkk.net and/or google new black panthers) then raceism is never going anywere. i Pray for grant and his family and hope that there is equal punishment amung the officer.

Unregistered user

u fool...

[deleted]... he shot him o purpose, cops dont accidentally shot white males with remotes do they... you know what the ratio is genius... you should get another video card... or another computer... or hell maybe another brain.

Unregistered user

It saddens me to see so many

It saddens me to see so many posts void of any social perspective or compassionate slant. I grew up in Oakland and encourage others to consider this incident with some mindfulness of what it is like to be young and black in this city. Poverty pervades here and it breeds frustration and disappointment. Popular culture glorifies a macho "hard" persona. The police department routinely is overworked and wary of the same people they have vowed to protect. You can imagine the kind of atmosphere this affords. These are just some of the reasons tensions have run high here for decades. Tragic incidents like these need to bring to the country's attention the deplorable conditions a generation...a culture are being subjected to. To hear these young people described as "animals" and referred to as "u people" is beyond comprehension. You would not be hard pressed to find that kind of language in the most radical of racist literature from decades past. This loss of life should not be written off as one murder among many or as a show of police brutality. Both take too cursory a look at something that runs much deeper. The truth is that complicated social forces are at work and they require a much deeper and more meaningful look.

Unregistered user

Officer involved shooting of Young Black Male

Wow. It's so unfortunate that in a time when this country where everyone as a whole should be focusing on getting back to the basics so that we can heal from racism, bad financial decisions, as well as other issues we now have something like this to also have to put the pieces together and then heal from. I truly believe that there's a cause and effect for everything that happens in life and this senseless situation isn't immune from those causes and effects. Each of us has to become responsible and accountable for ourselves first before we walk outside our doors to face the world each day. But even before that happens we've got to want to change. There's a scripture for those who believe in biblical teachings that says, "if my people, who are called by my name, will humble themselves and pray and seek my face and turn from their wicked ways, then will I hear from heaven and will forgive their sin and will heal their land." (2 Chronicles 7:14)

America, world that's the only way that this country, and world will ever experience peace, love, and respect again like it use to be.

"Lord I pray for our law enforcement officers everywhere who're called to protect and to serve. I pray that as they do the job that they took an oath to do that you will give them knowledge and sound guidance in dealing with they're everyday task. Then Lord I pray for our citizens. It takes a village to not only help raise a child, but Father help each of us all across this world to understand that it's going to take that sane village to help in keeping their members responsible and accountable for our everyday actions. And finally Lord, help us to humbles ourselves before you, turn from the old way of doing things, and then seek you for direction because that's the only way you're going to crate healing in our land. Thank you Lord for hearing my prayer in Christ name I pray, Amen."

Unregistered user

Banana republicans and assorted fascist cuntrees

Viva China, land of freedom, home of the brave. Yanks (jerks) get over yerselves, you've been a bunch of murdering scum with smiley hypo faces, criminals of the worst sort, the smile, the shake of the hand, the knife in the back. This mf ng cop killed a man in front of other cops... trusting they'd support him; and in front of a crowd of citizens trusting no one would care what they had to say. If not for the camera he would have no probs, as all the other murdering scum with badges have had no probs, and there are no real honest Men wearing badges to take them down. No, USA is Bushland, with farcical cops, fbi, cia all the way from top to bottom, corrupt and decadent to it's core. [deleted]

Unregistered user

End police brutality now!

Wikipedia defines police brutality as the intentional use of excessive force, usually physical, but potentially it can come in the form of verbal attacks, and psychological intimidation by a police officer. The Shooting of 22 year-old Oscar Grant of Hayward, California would fall under this definition. He had been detained and forced to lie chest down on the ground at Oakland's Fruitvale BART Station after 2 a.m. on New Year's Eve, after transit police responded to an alleged fight where no members of said fight where arrested or detained. He was surrounded and cooperative then executed with a shot to the back. Five days later the San Francisco Chronicle reports that the officer (identified by the paper as Johannes Mehserle a two year veteran of the BART police) has as yet given a statement to investigators about what actually happened that night. The reason being is that the BART police have no civilian oversight? In fact they are the only major police agency that operates with zero oversight. There is no BART board committee that monitors the BART cops, no independent investigative agency. And sadly this is not the first time the BART police have gotten away with murder. In 1992 the almost cartoonish named officer Fred Crabtree shot and killed a 19 year old warehouse worker named Jerrold Cornelius Hall with a shot gun blast to the back of his head. All because he fit the third had description the officer received of a man who allegedly stole a $60 walk-man from a BART passenger who later disappeared without a trace. On May 28th 2001 BART police officer Dave Betancourt shot and killed an unarmed naked man named Bruce Seward after finding Seward passed out near a dumpster. While police brutality is nothing new and has existed as long as there have been police men how many more lives must be lost before enough is enough. The Oakland police seem to be especially trigger-happy. On July 25 2008 near the exact same Fruitvale station where Oscar Grant lost his life, Officer Hector Jimenez shot and killed Mack Woodfox III (27 years-old). The officer claimed he appeared to be reaching for his waist band after a brief chase, but no gun was found on Woodfox. This was more than an isolated incident itself, it seems the same officer Jimenez and another officer shot and killed Andrew Moppin on New Year's Eve 2007 because they believed he was reaching for his waistband. Earlier this year Oakland police shot and killed Jose Luis Buenrostro in March. According to police the 15 year old pointed a sawed off shot gun at them in and are known for gang violence not far from down the road from Fruitvale Ave. A week prior the Oakland police shot and killed a 70 year old man who they claimed pointed a replica pistol at them. It's not just in Oakland of course in June of 2007 West Memphis police officer Erik Sammis shot and killed 12 year old DeAuntae Farrow when the child ran by him with a toy gun. He of course was cleared of violating the child's civil rights by the Department of Justice a few months later. We all know of the infamous cases of Sean Bell who the NYPD shot 50 times leaving his bachelor party or Abner Louima who was beaten and sodomized by the NYPD. And I don't think I have to mention the Rodney King beating. Thank goodness, because of that incident we now live in an era when every man woman and child can record these atrocities with our personal camera phones. Already several videos of the murder of Oscar Grant have surfaced. There are supposedly more out there confiscated by the BART police to cover their tracks. Conveniently their own station cameras happen to catch nothing of value according to their spokesmen. Video or not the eyewitness accounts of the event are the same if not worse than the video. The victims own friends who were forced to sit quietly hand cuffed as their friend was shot to death, state that not only was Grant cooperating, but he was instructing them to do the same. The question essentially here is how we as citizens of this great police state will do about this; will we allow this type of reckless behavior to continue; for what-Safety? This is not protection, this is imprisonment unless you get out of line then you are gunned down in cold blood. In October 2005 France erupted into cross country riots triggered by the murder of two unarmed teenagers by police who had chased them into a power substation. In 2008 civil unrest broke out in Greece on December 6th when 15 year-old Alexandros Grigoropoulus was shot and killed by policemen. The death of Grigoropoulus resulted in large demonstrations that quickly escalated into widespread rioting. The worst Greece has seen since 1974. Yet on Monday in Oakland where many have been brutally gunned down by the so-called law enforcement only twenty people turned out to protest. On Wednesday at 3 P.M., there will be another chance to mobilize. Though this is not a localized event, there are many of you reading this across the internet, that do not live remotely close to Oakland much less the Fruitvale station less than a mile from my home, but you can become vocal about the brutality of the police in your area, and around the world. We can stand up now or wait until we become a country like Burma where the very act of protesting with signs and songs will end in our death or disappearance. This is a slippery slope we have been descending down since the days of the Pinkertons. Now in this new century, on the verge of a historic presidency, how much longer will we allow ourselves to be at the mercy of these monsters? How many more young men will have to die? How long will it be before it's you or someone you know?Long Live the Revolution!

Hanumansboi's picture

Hanumansboi

  • United States
  • cook

For your consideration

http://www.sfbayview.com/2009/oscar-grant-young-father-and-peacemaker-ex...

4 Responses to “Oscar Grant, young father and peacemaker, executed by BART police”
1. curt, on January 7th, 2009 at 7:05 pm Said:
“Peacemaker”??? Isn’t this guy a repeat convicted felon who just got out of prison and had been to court a dozen times in three years? I agree that the officer that shot him needs to be brought to justice, but why spin Grant as something he’s not? It *should* make no difference what was in his past…but spinning him for what he’s not isn’t doing him any kind of service either.
2. willa, on January 7th, 2009 at 7:38 pm Said:
to curt.. AMEN someone is sticking up for the truth! Cuz no, Grant wasn’t a peacemaking angel he now seems to be. He was also the instigator of a fight about a yearish ago that got his friend Fumar killed.
I agree the cop is in the wrong wholey and needs to be put on charges but if you watch the video you can see that BOTH officers (including the officer firing) are shocked a gun was fired and not a taser. The officer definately needs to be brought up on charges though.
The only other problem I have with this whole issue on the victim side is everyone loves to throw race into it! he was a MAN that should be enough but never is. If it had been a white/Latino/Asian guy shot all this protesting and stuff wouldn’t be happening. But because he was black then it had to be racism.. well seeing it that way makes the people making it about race the biggest racists in my mind.. I have less empathy for the victim when people try to make it what it isn’t.
That all said.. prayers to the family of Oscar as your pain I am sure cannot be tolerable :(

Unregistered user

Grant WAS Murded

There Is NO Fucking Way That That Rasist Arsehole Of A Cop, Made A Mistake.
HE Knew He Had His Gun, He Murded Grant!!!!!!!.
That Cop Deserves The Death Penilty!!!!.
SO Fucking What, If Grant Had A Long List Of Crime!!!.
He Was Murded By A Rasist Cop!!!!!!!!!..

Unregistered user

I wonder if you are a black

I wonder if you are a black man living in this area. I am a very light-skinned black man living in alameda county. I used to work early hours and would be on the street walking to work at 4am. Almost daily I was stopped by a sheriff and asked for my green card. When I told them I was born in San Francisco and was black they laughed and left me alone til the next time. Tell me that is not racism. Did you see the news of the BART board meeting? Ms. Murray was sitting on the board meeting and rolling her eyes, What is that about.

I feel for the Grant family. That was a horrible thing to happen to him and the rest of this country. Where else can you commit MURDER on tape and seen by witnesses and yet refuse to answer questions. Only in america and only if the VICTIM was black.

Ok, so maybe he was shocked the gun was a gun and not a taser, but why would you taze someone who is already under control, has an officer's knee on his neck, and yet another taser already pointed at him. There was no need.

For years I have complained that police are not only supposed to enforce the law but follow the law as well. Countless times that is not the case. In 1997 my mother was called a blind bitch and called a welfare hoe by an Oakland police officer. She called for his supervisor to come out for a complaint. When we came out to meet with her, it just so happened we knew her. Imagine the shock on his face. He could look at my mom after that. My mother has worked for as long as I can remember so she is not a "welfare hoe" and she wears glasses because she was assaulted and stabbed in her face. She let him have it. She told him "in the future watch your mouth, you will never who you are talking to". But he should have been disciplined but wasn't.

Racism is real We feel it everyday. So please, don't speak on what you do not know..............

Unregistered user

Criminal thugs put themselves in bad positions

The officer made a tragic mistake.
The victim is a criminal with a record. Hard info to find, disappearing from media stories.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/28521292/

Grant also had a criminal record; according to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, Grant served several months in state prison in ...

Shocking police blunder caught on phone camera
France24, France - Jan 6, 2009
The victim, Oscar Grant, held a criminal record. The bullet fired by the BART (Bay Area Rapid Transport) police officer shot through Grant's body, ...

Unregistered user

i agree that the gunshot

i agree that the gunshot should have never taken place but with the crowd acting all rowdy and all, surely didnt help. maybe if u guys didnt act the way u did, the cop wouldnt have slipped and fired that gunshot. has it ever occured that maybe the crowd caused it? i mean if u were interogated by a bunch of people, wouldn't u get nervous and do something stupid? geez, u guys need to take responsibility as well. im sure he didnt want to kill the guy jeopardizing his career and ruining his life.

and for those of u that have nothing better to do than to cause problems, u are worse than the police. i mean, y the f**k would u go out hurting others? u feel pain, dont u think others would too? y would u want to take it out on the innocent? whats done is done. what u need to do now is to make things better, not worse. live and learn, otherwise, ull never get the respect u want in life. IM SURE THAT OBAMA WOULD NOT HAVE ACTED THAT WAY IN A SITUATION LIKE THIS. THAT IS WHY HE IS WHERE HE IS TODAY!

"when u feel disrespected, it is the way u carry urself."

Unregistered user

if yu watch the video clip

if yu watch the video clip again like im sure you have you will notice the crowd goes from inquisitive to rowdy only once they start beating the shit out of him. People walk over to have a look and get spoken to like they are misbehaving 4yr olds instead of the people paying police officers there salaries.

Now you make a valid question when asking why wold people go out to hurt others? but the point is that the police no matter what the situation have to treat people as innocent till proven guilty. Now if someone from the public decided to get 4 buddies and kick the crap outta someone they'd go to jail right?, espicailly if he died as a result, if someone shot someone in the back at close range it would mean a life sentence. so why when a police officer does it do people have to protest/riot/take a stand for something to be done.

i know if i had been there regardless of the colour of the victim i would have marched, regardless of the colour of the officer i would have marched. most peole at the march werent there to riot, nor did their care about race, they just wanted justice to be done and a benchmark t be set. if every police officer knew they could get away with murder regardless of guilty or innocent people would die. and that would bring in an organisation simliar to hitlers government, where chaos could become a slaughter because police felt intimidated by a crowd.

this means the training that the taxpayers paid for is not working. And if that is admitted then the government might aswell admit that iraq and iran both have moles in the CIA and American Military.

Unregistered user

Wow! you are not only a

Wow! you are not only a racist, but very uneducated and stupid.

Unregistered user

racism

the person who wrote this comment is a racist ass....

Unregistered user

The blood sucking personal injury trial lawyer should be put in

Jail
Oakland should sue him for all riot damage and containment cost. He is personally responsible for fanning the flames.
The officer made a tragic mistake, get over it. Every week in Oakland, one brother kills another brother for no good reason and certainly not by mistake. Where is the community outrage?
The animals in Oakland need very little persuasion to riot, burn and steal, not necessarily in that order.
Listen to the trash talk on all of the internet clips, the people are animals and are partially responsible for the tension and confusion of the moment.

Unregistered user

People are so quick...

people are so quick to call others animals. Why single out Oakland as a place of rioting burning and stealing? A very small percentage actually partake, and rioting is just as likely to happen anywhere else.

One person feeling like they're better than another fuels these situations where people get hurt while others feel entitled to hurting. because they're just animals, what do they deserve?

the crowd may have been partially responsible, but what else could have possibly happened when you have cops pinning down a man at a transit station? A crowd will gather, and if the cops get out of hand, the crowd will intensify the situation.

The cops are supposed to be trained to not let a situation get out of control. They are trained to not let the pressure of the moment influence their decision. They're also trained which side the gun is on and which side the taser is on. Obviously, cops everywhere need better training to avoid incidents such as this.

Unregistered user

I would like you to look in

I would like you to look in Oscar 4 year old daughter's eyes and tell her to get over it.

We're supposed to trust the police to be the peace officers they pretend to be and that’s where the outrage comes from.

Unregistered user

This is horrendous, but I

This is horrendous, but I don't like how the OP seems to be encouraging the idea of riots. "Could the images spark social unrest?" "Such an incident...could add fuel onto an already simmering fire."

We can only hope?

Unregistered user

to be or not to be

That is really a shame. I would not be a police officer in an area like that. That's a wild ass mob not ordinary every day people taking the metro. They should have called in riot police or something, but that just would have escalated the situation even more.

Just by chance you can't tell exactly what happens from the video of course. But from the looks of things it definitely is excessive force. The officer who fired the shot should be charged with something if they can prove he acted out of line (like the guy wasn't going for his gun.) Ugh, it's so not worth being a police officer in situations like that.

Unregistered user

ordinary people

why would a wild ass mob randomly show up?

these were ordinary people that turned into a mob once this police action occurred.

of course, as another poster pointed out, this is 2am new years 'ordinary people.' even closer to a mob just because everyone is drunk.

Unregistered user

You're so right...ppolice

You're so right...ppolice brutality is at the tip of everyone's tongue nowadays. Granted there are situations where this is the case but in many, it's grey area.

Unregistered user

no grey area here and yes to riots

i live in oakland, and i will be at the BART station tomorrow at 3 to protest with thousands of others. and YES there will be riots if this gets handled like Rodney King, Sean Bell, Diallo, and countless others. It's true that most of the US does not know about this YET. This is only the tip of the iceberg. It is different in that technology will speak the truth. There is no debating what happened. Let's wait and see how they try to poke holes in the footage that DOES NOT LIE. Most of Oakland, by the way, is an amazing, diverse, and lovely place to live. The cops here however MUST be in the top 3 or 5 of police brutality cases. F**K the police! I believe Oakland leads in the country for officer involved fatalities--if not in the top three. BUT I LOVE OAKLAND!!!

Unregistered user

This is not like Rodney

This is not like Rodney King's beating. That was 100% police brutality. This is a case of thugs charging cops repeatedly while they're trying to do their job. Most of the cops can't concentrate on the guy who needed to be concentrated on. No, they're concentrating on those harassing them. It's a horrible situation, and it would never have taken place if they hadn't harassed those cops that way. Some folks got to look in the mirror someday, and realize they aren't the cops equal(not while he is trying to arrest someone.)

Unregistered user

grey area

I don't agree with the riot. However, we have seen this episode before. In 1992 Jerold Hall was shot in the back of the head by a BART officer. That shooting was called justified despite what independant witnesses said. So this time around they will really have to take a hard look. Video is not the kind of witness you can discredit.

This time, for some ungodly reason this cop is not prosecuted, Burn Oakland from end to end. Just give me a five minute warning first.....

Unregistered user

That should be fun to watch on CNN.

"I believe Oakland leads in the country for officer involved fatalities--if not in the top three."

That wouldn't surprise me given the dense population of criminals in that area.

Unregistered user

It was 2 in the morning on

It was 2 in the morning on new years, obviously the metro will be packed with drunks and partiers. Call riot police? thats just stupid. the officers had everything under relative control by the time he shot, AND EVEN IF he mistook his gun for his tazer, he had no right to use the tazer anyways! THE SUSPECT WAS UNDER CONTROL. This is by far the most shocking police abuse that i've seen, and this officer should be sent to jail, or more appropriately, an asylum for the criminally insane. (btw thats not sarcasm) I would not be surprised if this caused riots, and i'd even understand. Stuff like this has been happening everywhere in the world (even here in montreal). Police have to understand that they are supposed to serve and protect the public, not assault, threathen and discriminate it.

Unregistered user

All you criminals hang together

Whats the matter, did the RCMP put you in place and hurt your feelings?
Law abiding citizens hang together too and understand that police dealing with animals will sometimes make mistakes in the heat of the moment. Fire Him! (oops, never mind, he did the right thing and quit). The victim did not deserve to die but the criminal victim also put himself in the position for something bad to happen, something normal law abiding citizens rarely worry about.

Unregistered user

you can be arrested for anything here

you can be arrested for resisting arrest.

there are so many little illegal things that cops have something on everyone - it's not so much being law abiding, rather being completely submissive to cops. which you may argue everyone ought to do.

but some people have dignity, and some people will not allow themselves to be submissive. and some cops can be very antagonizing. if a cop was shouting epitaphs at you you might get a little bugged out to. maybe do something stupid.

"criminals" are integrated. I don't know where you get the view that only criminals have problems with the cops - I just don't think you've ever really looked into what happens. There's not good people and bad people. just people.

Unregistered user

There won't be any riots

There won't be any riots because most US citizens will never even hear about it.

Unregistered user