





Images: William Murphy on Flickr
If the Irish people vote "No" to the Lisbon Treaty today, the document will be binned. A traditionally pro-Europe nation, last week the polls showed a change in opinion, with "No" coming out as the likely winner. Irish voters from both sides tell us why the treaty is "scary".
The Lisbon Treaty, signed last December, is an amendment to the proposed European Union constitution that was quashed by "No" votes in French and Dutch referendums in 2005. While most of the EU's 27 states chose to let their MPs make the decision this time round, Ireland's constitution forbids this, and the republic goes to the polls tomorrow. Pro-EU observers wait nervously for the results, after a poll published by The Irish Times on Friday (6 June) saw 5% more voters saying "no" (35%) rather than "yes" (30%). If the Irish say no, the treaty will have to be forgotten.
Kevin Foley is a chartered accountant from Blackrock, Dublin.
I decided
as soon as the treaty came out to vote no. The parties never actually explained
why we should vote yes, the best they could manage was "vote yes because it's
good for Ireland and good
for Europe"! They've resorted to scare
mongering, stating that our position will be damaged, that everyone will look
down on us, that we'll loose jobs and investment etc [if we vote no]. In
reality this is all rubbish.I'm not against Europe but I don't see any need for further integration. I do not wish to see a European superstate. It [the treaty] enshrines European Law in the Irish Constitution as superior. The decisions of the Irish people will be given to faceless civil servants and judges in Strasbourg and Brussels. This alone is scary. We've got a constitution for a reason - it's there to protect us.
It's a typical Irish outlook to get down and kiss feet. But our success is not all down to the EU - people still have to go out and work to make the changes. There is no good argument for the treaty and plenty of good ones against it. So for sure I will be voting no."
Michael Seery is a chemistry professor at the Dublin Institute of Technology.
I just
don't think this [treaty] should be put to the people. It's all about policy
and procedures - This should be decided by our parliament. Sinn Fein is the
only major party against the vote but there are these minor Christian groups
campaigning and because of the 50-50 fair approach to both sides in Irish
broadcasting, these crazy people have been given airtime. They're just using
scare tactics.There's an attitude now that "we've got as much as we can, let's get out now". We've done extremely well in terms of the budget and human rights. And this constitution won't change anything. It's obvious we have to make this change. As much as I would like us to have a permanent commissioner in Brussels, you can't with growing numbers of member states, so it's got to go on a rotational basis."
I'm
undecided right now. I was going to vote yes but I was swayed a little from
listening to chat programmes on the radio. They're saying the government is
rushing into it and I do agree - they haven't even read it themselves! And
those who have say its gobbledygook. Also, the rest of Europe
hasn't been given a chance. That's not fair.For us the worry is that France and Germany want to get rid of our 12.5% corporate tax rate [in the France it's 34.5% and in Germany 38.6%] which has brought an awful lot of US companies into the country and we could lose that. We are at a disadvantage because of our location and being an island. At this stage I think it would be safer to vote no as a precaution. For now, I've been reading the paper as the subject is not allowed on TV or radio for the final 24 hours."
Comments
We should be grateful for the EU
Submitted by Sheila Rooney (not verified) on Mon, 16/06/2008 - 12:32.Being part of the European Union has had social benefits which surpass the economic advantages we have felt so far. As a country we have had to wake up to a realisation that there are bigger problems than the ones we have been facing in Northern Ireland in the previous decades and doing so has given us a sense of perspective that we as an off shore island of an off shore island, have been lacking. For this and so much more, we should be grateful.
Unregistered user
Your headline
Submitted by Kevin, Dublin (not verified) on Fri, 13/06/2008 - 18:19."EU referendum in Ireland: "We've got as much as we can, let's get out now"
Your headline shows you have no idea why people in Ireland voted no to the Lisbon Treaty. Ireland and the Irish people are very happy to be members of the EU. This no vote is not the people of Ireland saying no to the EU or getting out while the going is good.
The people of Ireland said no to this treaty and as a result there has been a rise in anti-Irish sentiment in the foreign press and in Brussels. We have been threatened and been called mentally ill by officials of the EU. I voted no and I am happy we defeated this treaty as it has allowed the people of Ireland to see the true colours of some of our so called friends in both the EU and foreign media.
I voted no to this treaty because the EU and Irish government failed to sell me the treaty. The reason Irish people voted no is more complex and ranges from anger caused by threats made from foreign MEP's to a loss of trust in the Irish government amongst others.
Unregistered user
Spanish: Please say NO to
Submitted by anako (not verified) on Thu, 12/06/2008 - 09:28.Spanish:
Please say NO to that "secret", undemocratic Treaty!!!
In the name of all of us who can not be heard.
Save Europe from wild neo-liberalism.
http://elproyectomatriz.wordpress.com/2008/03/10/tratado-de-lisboa-europ...
http://elproyectomatriz.wordpress.com/2008/03/17/tratado-de-lisboa-europ...
http://elproyectomatriz.wordpress.com/2008/02/26/%c2%bfconstitucion-euro...
Unregistered user