Tax dispute gets ugly as protesters go on rampage in eastern China

A police bus on fire during unrest in the town of Zhili. Photo posted to Chinese social networking site Weibo.
 
More than a thousand people took to the streets in eastern China Thursday night, in a second day of demonstrations over tax hikes for store owners. On their way to local government offices, protesters destroyed cars and clashed with riot police.
 
The unrest began on Wednesday when a children’s clothing store owner refused to pay taxes because the amount had raised sharply from last year. Local residents claim he was physically attacked by the tax collector for his refusal. State-run media have said the victim then rallied other shop owners in an attempt to retaliate - though our Observer says they just wanted to negotiate lower taxes – and then, the situation got out of hand.
 
Some people in the town of Zhili in Zheijiang province, where the protests are taking place, have said they are not only venting anger at the tax hike, but also against what they perceive as discrimination against migrant workers. Other reports have suggested that migrant business owners were required to pay higher taxes than locals, though this was not the case our Observer encountered.
 
In what has now become customary during periods of unrest in China, the government has blocked results for key search terms – in this case, “Zhili” – on Chinese search engines and social networking sites.
 
Rioters attack a police bus that was apparently left unattended. They throw stones at it, and at 2'00 and 5'20, they attempt to overturn it. 
Contributors

“I just wanted to negotiate lower taxes, but some workers are immoral and prefer to destroy everything”

Mr. Wan runs a business in Zhili.
 
My wife and I moved from our home province of Jiangxi [which neighbours Zhejiang province] to Zhili in 1998. We run a children’s clothing store, just the two of us. Many migrants come here with friends from their hometown to run children’s clothing workshops together. According to the law, business owners must pay taxes on five sewing machines, even if the owner has less than five machines. We own only two, but pay for five. Last year, the tax was 300 yuan [around €33] per sewing machine per year. But this year it’s soared to 625 yuan [around €70]. We feel this is too high.
 
On October 26, a woman refused to pay this tax and was beaten up by tax officers. She was hospitalised. So workers began a strike to try to negotiate a lower tax. That afternoon, we went to the local government’s offices. There were thousands of us workers. The authorities deployed Zhili’s entire police task force. We said the tax had increased too much, and that we couldn’t accept it, but the government kept its tough stance. I returned home; afterwards, the police beat many people up. One man who works next door to my workshop was detained.
 
Protesters flood the streets of Zhili. At 5'20, a group of protesters overtturn a parked car. 
 
In the evening, enraged workers tried to damage a random Audi, whose driver managed to flee and drove into many workers in the process. So the violence escalated from there. I later saw dozens of vehicles that were smashed, overturned or burned, including police cars. Some people took this opportunity to create chaos; I don’t know who these people were. Yesterday many more cars were destroyed. We didn’t dare go out after sunset.
 
I just wanted to negotiate with the government, but our negotiations failed. It is impossible to defeat the government anyhow. I will have to pay the tax in the end. However, some workers are immoral, and prefer to destroy everything. Now that things have turned ugly, we can’t work normally.
 
All workshops here have stopped production. The roads out of Zhili are blocked by police, so we can’t distribute our goods anyway. The authorities are urging us to resume production, but we don’t dare. Some stores reopened, and were destroyed by rioters. The owners were badly beaten. Schools have suspended classes as well.”
 
All photos posted to Chinese social networking site Weibo. 

Comments

Reply to comment | The FRANCE 24 Observers

Great work! Let me simply authorize myself into your guestbook to show
you the amount of i value your work.

Reply to comment | The FRANCE 24 Observers

Greetings! Quick question that's totally off topic.
Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly?
My weblog looks weird when viewing from my apple iphone.
I'm trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to fix this problem.

If you have any recommendations, please share. Appreciate it!

Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose.

As per Jing Liu's 'Understanding China Through Comics', this conflict would seem to be a modern day demonstration of Legalism, as prosecuted by the central government in Beijing, that is still working on the principles of Legalism in concert with central government, that pertained to the Zhou dynasty (1046-256 B.C.): 'Group families into units of 5. If anyone commits crime. All 5 families will be punished.' In this case, it is 5 sewing machines. In Beijing, 5 is magic number.

The argument for strong central government, is that without strong central government, China would be consumed by violence. Perhaps this is true, on a grand scale. But the grand scale comes from the small scale, such as this. Thus, Beijing would do well to take a more reasonable line, since forcibly raising tax revenue from hand-to-mouth traders, with which to buy up EU and/or US debt, to prop up China's export driven economy, is not a viable policy.

Furthermore, if strong arm tactics such as those that are being complained about, are necessary to secure the territory of China, it would suggest that China is not a viable concept, and will, all things being equal, be more likely to break up into the many territories, that pertained to the post-Qing era, of the 1920s.

I think that this is

I think that this is interesting, because it shows that there has been a shift in priorities of Chinese over the last 20 years. In 1989, students tried to destroy the regime that they deemed unfair and undemocratic. Now, protestor do not seek to destroy the system, but merely to make it a little fairer. I am an undergrad student, and I've just started a paper on the topic, so this article is very interesting.

As for your argument on legalism, I am not sure that legalism is still the dominant trend of the CCP today. They are certainly pragmatic, and under Jiang Zemin, they have given the law a stronger role. But this article is about the migrant workers, who arguably have it the worse under the CCP rule, as they are not recognized by the law and are treated almost as badly as slaves by businesses, who pray on them because they are not protected under the law. Therefore, there are the group that is the most likely to threaten the CCP and form organize dissent, which is very scaring to the CCP since 89.

Then again, I am not an expert on Legalism.

Reply to comment | The FRANCE 24 Observers

You can certainly see your enthusiasm within the work you write.
The arena hopes for even more passionate writers
such as you who are not afraid to mention how they believe.
At all times go after your heart.

Close