Sri Lanka, Russia, Guinea... a sad state of affairs for human rights in 2009

Amnesty International released its annual report on Thursday, weighing up the world's worst human rights offenders of 2009, country by country. Our Observers from some of the 159 countries on the list give their reactions.

What's the state of human rights in your country? Register with The Observers and send us your account.

SRI LANKA: “When the [Tamil] massacres were happening they went unheard of”

X, who prefers not to be named, is an exiled journalist from Sri Lanka. He is a member of Europe-based activists Journalists for Democracy in Sri Lanka.

The most striking event in Sri Lanka was the [Tamil] massacres in the northern conflict areas that took place in the run up to the end of the war last year. When the massacres were happening they went unheard of, and it was only because we managed to acquire video footage of one of the massacres and capture the interest of the mainstream press that the issue became publicised in August 2009. And although the war has ended, the conflict is now even deeper, because the proof of the violations has polarised the issue.

If you consider human rights violations by the number of body bags, then you would say that the situation is better today. But if you look at it in terms of freedom of speech for journalists, then the government hasn't shown any progress this year. For the 23 journalists who ‘went missing' before March 2009, no investigation has been launched."

RUSSIA: “The murder of human rights lawyer Stanisla Markelov”

Oleg Kozlovsky is a human rights campaigner from Moscow.

For me the most striking event has to be the murder of human rights lawyer Stanislas Markelov and the death of journalist Anastasia Barburova, who was shot while rushing to his aid.

I can't see any progress from my point of view. [President Dmitry] Medvedev is no different from how [Prime Minister Vladimir] Putin was. They talk about democracy but there's no action; they create laws but they don't apply them.  

With no elections at present, we've got a bit of temporary stability, but the government will start to tighten the screws soon enough - we've got the legislative elections coming up [expected late 2011] and then the presidential election to follow [expected 2012]. Freedom of speech is certainly not going to see an improvement."

GUINEA CONAKRY: “I saw with my own eyes what happened in the stadium in Conakry”

Kouyate is a Guinean student.

I wasn't surprised to see Amnesty International point the finger at Guinea in its report. I saw with my own eyes what happened in the stadium in Conakry during the protest against the junta on September 28. The soldiers shot at people at point-blank range and women were raped. That's undeniable [Editor's note: more than 150 civilians died in the massacre, according to a UN report].

The problem is that those responsible weren't punished. It was the same after the last massacre in my country. And if things carry on in the same way, nothing will change. We'll be holding our presidential election on 27 June. I really hope we'll get a democratically elected president, someone who will first and foremost reform the justice system, and turn it into something strong and independent."

BURMA: “The number of political prisoners here increased to more than 2,200”

Khin Ohmar campaigns for human rights in Burma. She lives on the border between Thailand and Burma.

What we witnessed here in 2009 was the ongoing harassment, intimidation, arrest and imprisonment of democracy and human rights activists. Last year the number of political prisoners increased to more than 2,200. That includes aid workers, musicians and journalists. We've also seen an increase in the number of refugees fleeing across the border to Thailand and China because of increased military attacks on ethnic groups.

We need the ASEAN, UN, EU and US to stand up together to press this military regime to enter into dialogue and release all political prisoners. That is what's needed to bring Burma into a transition, and that's the only way. Burma will not turn into a peaceful state with this military might planning on holding onto power."

TUNISIA: “We’ve been included in Amnesty International’s reports for a long time”

Mokhtar Yahyaoui is a former judge from Tunis.

Tunisia has been included in Amnesty International's reports for a long time. It's the same thing every week. Repression, judicial problems, activists being hassled... Here's it's a case of keeping your mouth shut while they clamp down.

The most problematic part of 2009 was probably the crackdown on freedom of speech and the attack on the Tunisian journalists' union. There's an ongoing conflict between the dictator and everyone who fights for the freedom of the press. We're not asking for a press as free as say, in France, but something similar to the situation in Morocco or Algeria for example.

The government also needs to tackle the justice system, and soon. They need to give us a freer and stronger justice. The fact that they signed all the international human rights conventions, and even incorporated them into national law, doesn't mean anything until they start applying them. I know what I'm talking about; I was a judge for decades."

Comments

I'm actually from Russia and

I'm actually from Russia and I just want somebody to answer me a simple question - why, why do you hate us so much that you always say only bad things about us????????have you ever wrote anything positive about Russia???stop hating and stop teaching others how to live. Really, people,the world is changing it's not USSR anymore and you still think by Cold War standards, while there is no more Cold War anymore! Let's all be friends and love each other!
PS and russian people are NOT like those you always depict. we are beautiful and kind!)))

RE: Russia

Dear anastasia,

We certainly do not "hate" Russia or set out to depict the country in a negative light. Most of our posts about Russia are written by Russians. If you would too like to alert us on stories in Russia - whether positive or negative - we would be more than happy to receive your ideas.

Use the "Send us s a tip" tool on the right-hand toolbar.

Thank you,

Sophie

United Kingdom: The murder of human rights lawyer Abdel-salam

Abdel-Salam Hussain Abdel-Salam was murdered in his house in Lewisham March 15, 2010.

Just because a lawyer is murdered does not mean the country has human rights issues. Look at the US where everyday the police are beating black people on the street.

Russia should not be on the list with these war-torn third world countries.

Very selective report

I think the earlier email was making the point as to how selective your report was. Of course there are 150 countries covered but why single out a few from the underdeveloped. Why not tell us about some of the countries that hold themselves out as so called upholders and enforcers of human rights in the world - for example, France - 'allegations of police ill treatment and excessive use of force continued' or Britain where 'reports implicating the UK in grave violations of human rights of people held overseas continued to emerge' or the 'land of the free' the USA where 'further details emerged of toorture and other ill-treatment of detainees.'

RE: very selective report

Dear Unregistered user,

Unfortunately we only have so much time and so many resources for each post we publish. Therefore we selected 10 countries which were mentioned in the report and in which we had Observers who would be able comment. Five of those contacts were available - those which you see in the article.

That's why we asked other web users to contribute too - that way you can cover many others of the 159 countries included in the report.

If you're disappointed that certain countries weren't mentioned - mention them yourselves! The debate is now over to you.

Sophie, Editorial team, The Observers

What a funny load of crap.

What a funny load of crap.

What about Afghanistan/Iraq/Pakistan ??? "Happy state of affairs for human rights" when innocent people are bombed on the streets????

What about 1000's of Zimbabwe's children sanctioned to death ??? their right to medical care denied by same sanctions how many thousands died of colera???? is that a very happy state of affairs ??????

The places mentioned above (Burma, Russia, Sri Lanka and tunisia except for GUINEA CONAKRY which I'm ignorant about, but I can't take AI seriously anymore) here at least people don't explode in to pieces every day... sincerely that's not so "sad" for me... And ironically all these countries are moving forward with new economic realities which I doubt make some of these "good" guys or their paymasters "sad".

RE: what a funny load of crap

Dear Unregistered user,

We selected a few of the 159 countries on the list (as explained in the introduction: "Our Observers from some of the 159 countries on the list give their reactions").

Like we said, if you have an account from your own country, then please send it in.

"A sad state of affairs for human rights in 2009" referred to the situation worldwide, not in the three countries highlighted.

Sophie, Editorial team, The Observers

Amnesty International Human Right Abuse 2010 report

The actual report contains 159 countries. Although I have not purchased the report (which in my view should have be free), hope contains Ethiopia, for the many unreported human right abuses that takes place under the leadership of Meles Zenawi - the Prime Minister. This includes hundreds dead (actual reported figure of 200 people dead is a fraction of the actual number) during clash of the marred poll of 2005; including the decision of the Prime Minister to jail opposition groups. This year's election, which took place on Sunday May 23 is not much different than the last. Although only a 1/3 of the population registered to vote (hopes and morals are very low), and in spite of the optimistic international community reports, the election process was filled with intimidation and vote-rigging.

You can download it from

You can download it from their website for free

Close